Share this Story:
Starring: Thomas Horn, Tom Hanks and Sandra Bullock
1. tman1m said... on Feb 8, 2012 at 12:48PM
“You wouldn't be the first critic to argue that this film's (and book's) protagonist is on the edge between precociousnes and obnoxiousness, but your smug/superficial review (which appears to reveal you have not read the book) reads as overly harsh and especially hostile. Are we to assume that that 9/11 is "too personal" for any artist to try to speak to or intepret those events and how we were and are affected? Is it really a stretch to see how a family's story could be bookended by this tragedy and the ones that occurred in WWII? I notice you didn't mention "Reign Over Me," but I thought that film was quite effective in filtering the horrible events of that day through its effects on a particular family. Your venom appears colored by your general opinion of the director (sorry, but can't agree with your appraisal of The Reader either). I agree that this film had to walk a thin line between empathy and outright bathos, but I think it did so successfully, given the challenging premise.”
Article: For a true depiction of real friendship, see 'Me and Earl and the Dying Girl'
Article: Take a risk on some odd summer flicks
Article: Ever imagine what H.R. Giger’s home looked like? See if you were right by watching ‘Dark Star’
Article: How Mad Max pissed off the MRAs and won a huge female audience
Article: The new movie "Iris" peeks into the life of a fashion legend
Article: This year's PIFF entries teeming with vigor and variety
Article: Even once is too much for "Kill Me Three Times"
Article: Blueblood entitlement's on the dinner menu in "The Riot Club"
Powered by Clickability.
National advertising by VMG Advertising.