A lender's end to overages

Will new rules spur other banks to follow suit?

By Inman News Feed
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 20 | Posted Mar. 15, 2010

Share this Story:

Will new rules spur other banks to follow suit?

Jack Guttentag
Inman News

Bank of America recently delivered the following message to its loan officers: "Policy Change: Effective with initial locks on or after Jan. 21, 2010, overages will not be allowed on either purchase or refinance transactions."

Some years ago, I had occasion to compare the marketing of home mortgages by lenders in the U.S. with the marketing of carpets in Middle Eastern bazaars. The comparison favored the carpet merchants, who didn't pretend their prices were fixed. Virtually all carpet buyers know that in the bazaar, bargaining is the rule.

While less-competent bargainers may pay a little more, they are paying for their incompetence, not their innocence of the rules. In contrast, a large proportion of mortgage borrowers did not understand that they were in a mortgage bazaar -- they paid for their innocence.

The price of innocence is called an "overage." It is the difference between the price a lender posts with its loan officers -- which is the price the lender expects to receive -- and the price the loan officer (LO) charges the borrower.

If the posted price is 5 percent and zero points, for example, and the LO charges the borrower 5 percent and 0.5 point, the 0.5 point is the overage. Typically, the LO will get half. Interested readers will find a full discussion of how overages work on my Web site.

We have not always had overages. In the 1920s, before there were secondary markets, consumers who wanted mortgages visited the offices of commercial banks, savings banks, or savings and loan associations, and dealt with salaried employees who had no discretion or incentive to adjust prices.

Overages arose following the development of secondary mortgage markets after World War II. Secondary markets made it possible to go into the loan origination business without becoming a regulated financial institution. Because you could sell loans as fast as you made them, all you needed was a little capital and a line of credit.

These firms are "mortgage companies," or (as they much prefer) "mortgage banks." I sometimes refer to them as "temporary lenders" as distinguished from "portfolio lenders" who hold the loans they originate in their portfolios.

Mortgage banking developed its own operating methods and a culture to match that were very different from those of depository institutions. They invested very little in physical facilities designed to attract walk-in traffic during business hours. Instead, they retained loan officers (LOs) to actively pursue clients, as opposed to sitting behind a desk waiting for clients to appear.

To develop purchase-loan business, LOs courted real estate sales agents, making themselves available to the agents wherever and whenever they were needed to take a loan application, which might be on the hood of an automobile on a Sunday morning. To develop refinance business, LOs might camp out in the office of a public agency that maintains records of deeds and liens, developing lists of borrowers who might profit from a refinance.

Because LOs did most of their work out of the office, subject to little supervision, they were compensated largely or entirely on a commission basis. While legally employees of the mortgage bank, LOs operated largely as if they were independent contractors. And the more loans they brought in, the more independent they were.

Overages were part of the package. Most LOs wanted to be free to charge what the traffic would bear, and profit from it. The lender who wouldn't tolerate overages would lose LOs, and the most successful LOs would be the first to leave.

The LO-based mortgage origination system made the depository office obsolete as a source of mortgage loans. Depository institutions that wanted to be major players in the home-loan market had to hire their own loan officers -- or acquire an entire mortgage banking firm as an affiliate.

The affiliate approach was the more popular because it avoided clash between very different cultures.

I recall my shock when I joined the board of a large savings and loan association some years ago and found that the CEO was the third most highly compensated employee of the association. The two who earned more were LOs who had not yet been moved into a separate affiliate.

The general attitude of most depository institutions has been that overages were a necessary evil that they would like to eliminate, if they could do it without losing their best loan producers. Bank of America has evidently decided that that time had come.

Not the least of the reasons is that under revisions to Truth in Lending recently proposed by the Federal Reserve, lenders will not be able to share overages with LOs. This will eliminate the financial incentive for LOs to charge overages.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 20 of 20
Report Violation

1. george morgen said... on Mar 9, 2011 at 05:14PM

This is an international lending firm located in some countries,we offer all type of loans to interested persons for any purpose.contact us through this email address if you need a loan:

Report Violation

2. joseph amir said... on Apr 15, 2014 at 09:23PM

The opportunity is here for you to get what you have been looking for, the development and growth of the economy depends on investment and all business/startup needs funding to expand. It is time to move forward and establish. Joseph Amir investment company is out to help investors, enterpreneur, individuals and companies get the funding they needed.Contact us if you need loan.

Report Violation

3. wemasundas said... on Oct 28, 2014 at 12:51PM

“Hello Sir / Ma,
Are you seeking for legitimate and fast loan? Free collateral loans / non-collateral loans, we offer loan services of different types ranging from full loans to subordinate loans best designed for you. The loans are given at a very low interest rate. We offer mortgage, company, business, personal, housing, land acquisition and many more. No social security number is required and no credit check required 100% guarantee to the nation / world.Our dignity is to respect while providing the highest quality services, We will not also forget to bring to your notice that we grant loans to sincere and seriousminded customers that need to be uplifted financially with the help of loan / loans. Contact us now via our mailing address.
Mrs Wema Sundas.
Email: mrswemaloans@rocketmail.com”

Report Violation

4. AnonymousWEMA BRING LOANS TO ALL IN JUST 3% INTEREST RATE FOR XMAS! Email: mrswemaloans@rocketmail.com said... on Oct 28, 2014 at 12:56PM

“Dear Sir/Madam,
We the Wema Loans, Provides both long and short term loan financing. We offer secure and confidential loans at a very low interest rate of 3% per year.
We offer;Personal loans, Debt Consolidation Loan, Venture Capital, Business Loan, Corporate Loans, Educational Loan, Home Loan and Loans for any reason!
We are the trusted alternative to bank financing, and our application process is simple and straightforward. Our loan ranges from $5,000.00 (Five Thousand dollars ) to
$25,000,000.00 (Twenty Five Million dollars).
Additional Info: We're fast becoming the private, discreet, and service oriented lending choice for general loans. We're the company to turn to when traditional

lending sources fail. If you are interested do not hesitate to contact us with information’s below by
Email: mrswemaloans@rocketmail.com
1. Your Full names:
2. Contact address:
3. Occupation:
4. Your Contact Telephone Numbers:
5. Monthly Income:
6. Contact Email Address:
7. Loan Amount:
Mrs Wema Sundas.
Head, Loan Application Department,
Wema Loans,
mrswemaloans@rocketmail.com ..”

Report Violation

5. WORLDVIEW FINANCE LIMITED said... on Jan 10, 2015 at 04:42PM

“Do you need a loan?. if yes, send your application to us via our contact email at: worldviewfinancelimited@gmail.com for further proceedings.”

Report Violation

6. WORLDVIEW FINANCE LIMITED said... on Jan 10, 2015 at 04:42PM

“Do you need a loan?. if yes, send your application to us via our contact email at: worldviewfinancelimited@gmail.com for further proceedings.”

Report Violation

7. Mr Andrew Musungu said... on Jan 24, 2015 at 06:49AM

“Do You Need an urgent loan of any Amount? Then contact us now, we give out all
kinds of loans with a very low interest rate of 3%. Contact us with your name,
1)Full Names:................................................
6)Marital Status:........................................
8)Phone Number:.......................................
10)Monthly income:....................................
11)Next of Kin:..............................................
12)Loan Amount Needed:.............................
13)Loan Duration:...........................................
14)Purpose of Loan:.......................................

EMAIL musungu.andrewfirm@yahoo.com

Mr. Andrew Musungu”

Report Violation

8. jame said... on Feb 1, 2015 at 11:41PM

Do you need an urgent loan we offer worldwide loan to who in need of loan the business opportunity you having being looking for is here again. email us now at: Email jamefinancialcompany@gmail.com

1) Full Name:
2) Gender:
3) Loan Amount Needed:.
4) Loan Duration:
5) Country:
6) Home Address:
7) Mobile Number:
8)Monthly Income:
)Which did you here about us.

Best Regards.”

Report Violation

9. Dorene Zeller said... on Feb 17, 2015 at 02:29PM

“Have you been looking for a loan?Do you need an urgent personal or business loan?contact Dennis Hopkins Finance Home he help me with a loan of $300.000 some days ago after been scammed of $2500 from a woman claiming to been a loan lender but i thank God today that i got my loan worth $300.000.Feel free to contact the company for a genuine financial service. Email: dennishopkins_financehome@live.com or dennishopkins69@yahoo.com or www.dennishopkinsfinance.de.vu Tel: USA 12404374240 Tel:UK 447509546091.He is a trust worthy man.”

Report Violation

10. Dorene Zeller said... on Feb 17, 2015 at 02:30PM

“Have you been looking for a loan?Do you need an urgent personal or business loan?contact Dennis Hopkins Finance Home he help me with a loan of $300.000 some days ago after been scammed of $2500 from a woman claiming to been a loan lender but i thank God today that i got my loan worth $300.000.Feel free to contact the company for a genuine financial service. Email: dennishopkins_financehome@live.com or dennishopkins69@yahoo.com or www.dennishopkinsfinance.de.vu Tel: USA 12404374240 Tel:UK 447509546091.He is a trust worthy man.”

Report Violation


“Do you need personal loan? Does your firm,company or industry need

financial assistance? Do you need finance to start your business? Do

you need finance to expand your business? We give out loan to

interested inviduals who are seeking loan with good faith. Are you

seriously in need of an urgent loan contac us at Email:

Your Full Details:
Full Name:
Loan Amount Need:
Loan Duration:
Phone Number:
Applied before?
Monthly Income:
You are to send this to our Company Email Address:


Report Violation

12. Mr Akim Lim said... on Mar 17, 2015 at 12:50PM

“Hello people pf Singapore, i was look for a loan and i was scam twice, until i meet this legit lender who lend me S$100,000SGD, in just for 24hours my loan is transferred to me.i we advice you to contact him via akimlim_loanfirm19@yahoo.com”

Report Violation

13. LOAN APPLICATION:testimony.goodwill.loan@gmail.com said... on Mar 28, 2015 at 11:10AM


Apply for a quick and convenient loan to pay off bills and to start a new financing your projects at a cheapest interest rate of 3%. Do contact us today via: testimony.goodwill.loan@gmail.com with loan amount needed as our minimum loan offer is 1,000.00 to any choice of loan amount . I am certified ,registered and legit
lender . You can contact me today if you are interested in getting this loan, contact me for more information about the loan process, process like the loan terms and
conditions and how the loan will be transferred to you. I need your urgent response if you are interested.


(1)Full Names:
(2)Amount Needed as Loan:
(3)Phone Number:
(7)Monthly Income:
(8)Marital Status:
(9)Have you applied before:
(10)Loan Purpose:

NOTE:All Responses should be forwarded to: testimony.goodwill.loan@gmail.com for quick processing.
Thank You,

Testimony Goodwill

Report Violation

14. Campbell Reid said... on Apr 5, 2015 at 11:17PM

“Hello applicant

I am Mr. Campbell Reid and i give out loans at an interest rate of 3% and i am a real and legit lender who give out all kinds of loans you need.

If interested in the offer, contact us today at reid3133@gmail.com or website: http://reid3133.wix.com/campbellreidloanfirm.

Campbell Reid.”

Report Violation



Attention To The World,

If you need a genuine and reliable loan help,and don’t want to be a scam victim,I think this is for you.This is a testimony on how,I was ripped off by some idiot that calls themselves lenders,and how I finally got my financial freedom through a God sent helper that finally gave my life a meaning,with the least cheapest rates as to 2% interest and little TOKEN other requirements and they don’t give a damn to your credit score…For more info on how to reach this great man just email him now and tell him that Oscar Max testify about him on the internet his email address is:testimony.goodwill.loan@gmail.com”

Report Violation

16. Mr.Scott said... on Apr 20, 2015 at 04:22PM

“Good day everyone.
This is Scott Spencer { Micro finance Foundation Company} will give Loan to company and individually if you have a bad credit you can contact us at via scttspencer7@gmail.com you must have the loan without any stress, we offer loan to Asia Europe Australia and America Africa also, and will treat customer very well they are free to make their opinion how they want their loan our interest rate is cheap and affordable, you will receive it faster just a little time difference from western union and money Gram ,we don’t waste client time because as they receive it they recommend more customers to us.

Report Violation

17. panwesley said... on Apr 21, 2015 at 04:59AM

Quick approval on Loan
We offer easy Loan to all emergencies
We have solutions for your needs with our money unsecured Loan.
We do large personal Loan and business Loan from 5000 to 20000000
One day approval No credit check, no collateral.
Email us today via (panwesley2010@yahoo.com) for more information.
Let's help! We can do it.

Report Violation

18. Amuta racheal said... on Apr 23, 2015 at 06:02PM


To properly introduce myself, I am Mrs Racheal. a private
lender i give out loan at 3% interest rate. This is a financial
opportunity at your door step, apply today and get your fast loan.
There are many out there looking for financial opportunity or
assistance all over the places and still yet they are unable to get
one. But this is a financial opportunity at your door step and as such
you can't afford to miss this opportunity. This service is render to
both individuals,companies,business men and women. The loan amount
available ranges from any amount of your choice.For more information
contact us via email: expartfinanecloans@gmail.com


Full Name:
Personal Phone Number:
Have you applied before?:
Marital Status:
Loan amount needed as loan:
Loan Duration:
Monthly Income:

Contact Via email: expartfinanecloans@gmail.com

I gladly await your swift response,

Warm Regards,
Mrs Amuta Racheal.

Report Violation

19. smith said... on Apr 24, 2015 at 07:21AM

“Do you need a loan to pay off your bill or in need of financial help with a loan you can contact us now for a loan if you are serious in getting it surely we will help you out okay @austinekingsloanfirm@gmail.com

Report Violation

20. Daniel Steve said... on Apr 28, 2015 at 03:32AM

“Hello Everyone I am Daniel Steve from Texas, USA. I will like to share the goodness of God in my life after so many months of trying to get a loan on the internet and was been scammed so i became restless and desperate in getting a loan from a legit lender online. But as God would have it, i saw a comment from a friend called William Ken and he talked about this legit loan company where he got his loan fast and easy without any stress so he introduced me to a man called Mr Mason Diego who controls a firm called Diego Loan Company, So i applied for a loan sum of ($170,000.00USD) with low interest rate of 2%, so the loan was approved and deposited into my bank account in less than 48hrs, that was how i was able to get back on my feet to keep my broken business running and also to pay off my bills so i am advising everyone of you who is interested in getting a loan without collateral, no credit check, no co signer with just 2% interest rate and better repayment plans/ schedule, to please”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)