Dems Attack Corbett at City Hall Health-Care Rally

By Matt Petrillo
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 2 | Posted Apr. 7, 2010

Share this Story:

Photo by Matt Petrillo

The health-care debate is still far from over (even though President Obama signed the bill two weeks ago): U.S. Reps. Chaka Fattah and Bob Brady held a rally Tuesday at City Hall to protest Attorney General Tom Corbett’s lawsuit that questions the legislation’s legality.

Corbett is running for governor, in case you didn’t know, and Dems hope to use health care—and the lawsuit—against him.
M. Nutt also appeared at Tuesday’s rally, which attracted about 50 people, including PhillyNow. (That’s quite a turnout.)

“The argument is that we shouldn’t be fighting something that’s now been passed by Congress, signed by the president. There’s a critical health-care need for all Pennsylvanians and all Americans,” the mayor says.

But when asked about Corbett’s main beef with the bill—that it is unconstitutional for Washington to force citizens to purchase health insurance (or else pay a fine)—the hizzoner looked confused: “Well, I think there’s an option where you can opt out of that. There’s a part, I think, that says you don’t have to have health care.”

He thinks.

How can he speak out against the bill if he doesn’t even know its stipulations? Either you are pregnant, or you aren’t. There’s no in-between, people.

(By the way, in case you were wondering, there is NO opt-out option. Either you get health insurance, or you pay a $695 annual fine. There are exceptions for low-income citizens. We would like to know, however, if the annual fee is more than the health insurance plan itself. That would create some problems, no?)

Anyway, we digress.

Fattah also showed up (more than fashionably late), and accused Corbett’s actions of being politically motivated.

“I don’t think Corbett has any argument, I think it’s a fatally deficient legal matter. And now, what they want to do is argue against people being getting covered. So, I think we’ll see him in court. The beauty of our country is that the courthouse doors are open to anyone, including a misinformed attorney general,” he says.

But isn't Corbett completely within his jurisdiction to challenge the bill? He's our attorney general. He challeges stuff for a living.

Marc Stier, Pa.’s director of Health Care for America Now, says anyone who thinks like Corbett shouldn’t be governor of Pennsylvania.

“Mandating people to get it is perfectly reasonable,” he says. “It’s just another program like Social Security or Medicare, which works through the tax system, so there’s no serious Constitutional argument against it. It’s totally fallacious.”

Democrats are trying to make Corbett own up because Corbett’s motives probably center on the future of his political career. But, hey, let’s be real. They’re probably doing it for the sake of their own careers, too.

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 2 of 2
Report Violation

1. corey said... on Apr 7, 2010 at 12:26PM

“This article is fascinating (no it isn't).”

Report Violation

2. Ray said... on Apr 8, 2010 at 10:57AM

“Does Tom Corbett believe Health Care is a Right for all American?
Support The PA Single Payer bill and you don't need a mandate or Tom Corbett.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Corbett to PA: No Health Care For You!
By Randy LoBasso

Our Attorney General is wasting no time trying to deny Pa. residents from receiving the benefits of the new federal health-care bill. Here comes the lawsuit.

Related Content

Trouble In Paradise For AG Tom Corbett
By Randy LoBasso

Tom Corbett's outrage against the health-care bill has taken the voting public's eyes off his real winning issue. Or were their eyes ever there in the first place?

RELATED: AP Takes Notice of Our Indifference To Pa. Guv Race

Related Content

Now Joe Hoeffel Wants Your Attention
By Randy LoBasso

Like AG Corbett and State Sen. Williams before him, Joe Hoeffel is saying things to get attention in the little-noticed race to replace Fast Eddie.

RELATED: Nutter Endorses Guy Who Wants Lock Up Mom & Dad U.S. To PA: No Tolls on I-80; PA to Self: Damn Superhighways for PA! (Just Don't Ask About the $)

Related Content

Cash Rules Everything Around Sen. Williams
By Randy LoBasso

Anthony Williams campaign for governor is raising some big cash from unexpected places (for a Democrat.)

RELATED: Sen. Williams Is On a Roll! Pa. Guv Debate: Sustainability Bluer State? Maybe Not