Glenn Beck is Right

It's time for us to find the people responsible for this mess and hold them accountable.

By Steven Wells
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 3 | Posted Apr. 6, 2009

Share this Story:

I’m reading Retribution, Max Hastings’ epic history of the death throes of imperial Japan, after having just finished Dear Billy, a superbly written comic by Garth Ennis in which a raped British nurse takes revenge by suffocating captured Japanese patients. (The whole story is told through a love letter to an RAF pilot, and it’s a shockingly good read).

Both the book and the comic focus on the messy, bloody death throes of the Japanese Empire—that bizarre combination of 20th century ultra-nationalism, 19th century imperialism and the medieval death cult of bushido (as worshipped by a wide-eyed Tom Cruise in his diabolically clumsy movie The Last Samurai). And both fixate on a desire for vengeance.

Ennis is perhaps best known for his work on Marvel’s Punisher, the story of man who tries to bury his remorse under a sea of bodies—and fails. One Ennis/Punisher storyline, "Kitchen Irish", ends when a young British soldier slots the young Irishman who killed his dad—and feels absolutely none the better for it.

I bring all this up in the wake of the increasingly irrational and hysterical Glenn Beck’s 9/12 campaign where Fox bollocks-talker Glenn tearfully implores Americans to feel the way they felt on the morning of the 12th of September 2001, and which Steven Colbert brilliantly parodied by appearing clutching a pump-action shotgun, a gas mask and colostomy pants.


An American friend received an e-mail on or around 9/12, the text told the story of a kid looking at a Ground Zero monument:

“Daddy, what were the Twin Towers?”

Dad explains that the landmarks were destroyed by Arab terrorists.

"Dad,” says the kid, “what’s an Arab?”

LOLgenoicide.

My friend wrote back angrily, asking that she not be sent any more racist e-mails.

The reply came: “You wouldn’t say that if you were a New Yorker. No city in the world has suffered as much as New York!”

To which, of course my friend could (but did not) respond with the following list: Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Tokyo, Berlin, Hamburg, Dresden, Warsaw, London, Bristol, Liverpool,Pompei, Carthage, Coventry, Atlanta, San Francisco …

But hey, I’m with Glenn.

Let’s do it all again. Let’s spunk a couple of million on Chinese-made U.S. flags. Let’s go beat the shit out of some Sikhs. Or some Hindus. Or anybody who kinda sorta looks a bit like a terrorist. Let’s give the same sordid cabal of war-profiteers andneo -imperialist wing nuts who spent the Clinton years secretly plotting the unprovoked invasion of Iraq another run out. What have we got to lose?

Those were the days my friends, if only we could get them back.

Beck has been rightly and widely mocked for his flailing, unfocused fury. What’s he against, exactly? And who are the “them” that he claims “we” surround? (I read this as whites surrounding blacks—does this make me paranoid?)

It seems—once one has picked one’s way through all the fake crying and strangely Mussolini-like hand gestures—that Glenn is calling from some sort of jihad-style vengeance on those who are destroying some vaguely defined American way of life.

Which I’m all for. I like a bit of catharsis. But for heaven’s sake let’s narrow down the list of really guilty men before we start. And let us—by all means—keep things judicial.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend

COMMENTS

Comments 1 - 3 of 3
Report Violation

1. Istvan said... on Apr 15, 2009 at 07:20PM

“The author doesn't take a stance, only mocks and waffles. Was that the intent? Beck's actually points are good ones. This article suggests some, like genocide, that are not points of Beck.

Contain your distaste of the points and consider them for a moment. America becoming socialist? You feel angry: America is nothing of the sort!! But consider: What is socialism?? Think about the definition. Think about this: "From each according to his ability, for each according to his need." Break it down. "From each according to ... ability." Next: "For each according to his need." Give to those deemed in "need" by the state.

Does that make socialism wrong? No. Does it make it right? No. The question is not is Beck right or wrong with his claims - he's got some very valid points. What, though, should we do about that? If we are becoming more socialist, is that a direction we'd like to continue in? If not, then why?

To the author of this article, and others: Listen. Even though you feel angry, and lots of other emotions when people say things you don't agree with, think a bit deeper and reflect. Maybe they have a good point. Beck certainly seems to, and that's not being properly acknowledged.


Report Violation

2. Cat said... on Apr 19, 2010 at 02:58PM

“Why must liberals always resort to race-calling..."angry white men"...

I'm beginning to wonder who are the biggest racists - the leftie labelers who see everything in black and white or us?”

Report Violation

3. Canof said... on Nov 8, 2010 at 06:46PM

“This article is full of petty insults and straw men. It's like I'm reading an extended comment written by a hateful troll instead of a thoughtful opinion piece. Pathetic, but sadly, all too typical.”

ADD COMMENT

Rate:
(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

British Conservatives Also Suck
By Steven Wells

So why do Americans love them? Also: 'The Wire' sucked. And so did 'Battlestar Galactica.' And so does Kill You In The Face. Anybody not mad yet?

RELATED: The end of ‘Battlestar Galactica’ Kill You in the Face

Related Content

The New York Post: Now With More Marxism!
By Steven Wells

Rupert Murdoch knows everything. He probably ordered the immediate adoption of the Bolshevik worldview throughout the News International print empire the minute he realized that only a total imbecile could possibly sing the praises of the so-called free-market in the deregulated nightmare horror wreckage of the voodoo economy.

Related Content

Newspapers Are Not Toilet Roll Manufacturers
By Steven Wells

They’re not McDonald’s. They’re not “businesses.” Oh, sure, they’ve got to make payroll. But they are not and cannot be run as out-and-out cash cows for the greedy and the idle.

RELATED: Imagine There's No Sports Page Too Cool for School What You'll Read When Newspapers Die Steven Wells Remembered

Related Content

Mr. Rogers Can Go to Hell
By Steven Wells

I personally spent last 25 years dumping the vilest invective imaginable on the heads of bands I consider bad, boring or merely annoying. Even with cancer, what right do I have to any immunity from those who slag back?

Related Content

The Great Unraveling of the Right
By Steven Wells

Are the Oath Keepers for The Man? Or for The People? And how are regular people supposed to tell "legitimate" conservatives from the nutter fringe these days, anyway?

RELATED: Save the Straights