Save Our Libraries! Again.

Think Philly is in trouble now? Watch how much worse it gets if the libraries close down.

By Brendan Skwire
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 7 | Posted Sep. 13, 2009

Share this Story:

Unless legislators take quick action, the Free Library of Philadelphia will close all of its branches in a few weeks.

Photo by Flickr user Mariela.

Well, it looks like the libraries, once again, are on the chopping block. And this time, it's ALL OF THEM.

Honestly, do we have to go through this exercise again? Let me be blunt and brief: libraries are more than just places to borrow a book or a DVD. They are a crucial part of the fabric of our community. They provide Internet access for low-income individuals and families, including access to help-wanted ads and online job applications. They provide free space for after-school programs for kids and community classes for adults struggling to earn their GED or learn English.

And they provide books. Remember them?

People who use Philadelphia's libraries are suffering right now: I know of several English as a Second Language (ESL) classes held at branches of the Free Library that have already been canceled due to shorter hours, disrupting the lives of immigrants trying to achieve citizenship -- and putting adult education teachers, already poorly paid, out of work.

Here's another reason the libraries are so important: Philadelphia is home to an astonishing number of poorly-educated adults: about 400,000 of our neighbors don't hold a high school diploma and 22 percent of the 1.1 million adults who live here don't even have basic literacy skills: that's around 250,000 people who can't make it through a comic book.

Before you go pointing your finger and crying "Tough luck for them," think about the impact. If you can't read or do basic math, you can't get a good job. If you can't get a good job, you don't earn as much. You don't earn as much, you can't contribute as much revenue to the economy and tax base. Heck, maybe you can't get a job at all, so you have to get welfare, which everyone pays for. Or maybe you start selling drugs (and I'm not talking about pot, which should be legal), which brings crime to your community and drives down your neighbors' property values. And hey, maybe you get arrested and now everyone has to pay for your three-hots-and-a-cot.

What's more, kids tend to emulate their parents. Low literacy and low educational achievement is handed down from one generation to the next, a vicious circle that has no benefit to anyone.

You wanna complain about taxes? Check this recent analysis from the Philadelphia Youth Network (PDF):

High school dropouts in Philadelphia city made a combined tax payment (including federal and state income taxes, Philadelphia city wage tax, social security payroll taxes, federal government retirement contributions, local property taxes, and state sales taxes) of just $4,250, which represents less than 40 percent of the mean combined tax payment of all adult residents of the city ($10,320). The mean combined tax payment among high school graduates was $9,320 or nearly 2.2 times higher than the amount paid by high school dropouts. Philadelphians with a bachelor’s or a higher college degree paid an average of $17,180 in tax payments.

But hey, we can't afford the libraries.

By the way, this says nothing about how the city's embarrassing low literacy rates affect us on a macro basis either. Let's say you're the president of some big corporation and you want to relocate. Besides tax rates and other expenses, one thing you're looking for is a skilled workforce. So where do you want to set up shop? (PDF) Boston, where in 2006 about 40 percent of residents had a bachelors degree; Stamford,Conn., where more than 42 percent of residents graduated from college; or Philly, where only 31 percent did?

Or what about the city's immigrants, whose numbers skyrocketed over the past couple of decades? According to the 2005 American Community Survey, 24 percent of Philadelphia’s immigrant population -- about 83,000 individuals -- live below the poverty line. Fully 150,000 working-age immigrant adults have limited proficiency in English, including 55,000 Spanish speakers and an astonishing 51,000 of immigrants from Asia. The National Institute for Literacy reports that of those families that speak Spanish in the home, more than 32 percent either have poor English skills or don’t speak the language at all. Now apply all that stuff above about the costs of unemployment and tax receipts to a population that relies on places like libraries for language instruction.

Here, I'll make it easy: according to a study done by the U.S. Department of Education, those in the lowest literacy levels were less likely to be employed, worked fewer hours in a week, and earned lower wages than those with higher literacy proficiency. In Philadelphia, this problem is compounded by the loss of manufacturing jobs, and the increase in service, medical, and technical jobs, all of which have made fluency in the English language more important than ever in obtaining and maintaining employment.

The geniuses in the Pennsylvania Legislature and in our own damn city administration may say "Well, we can't afford those libraries anymore," when the fact is we can't afford NOT to have them.

It's a flaming disgrace, and there is no shortage of bad actors to blame, from City Council for underfunding the pension plan, to the mayor who, according to community activist and former candidate for council Marc Stier, "only very haltingly and at the end of the process, tried to engage the public in fighting along side him for the city," to (who else) the batshit crazy Republicans in the State Senate who have this unholy fetish with robbing unionized workers of their right to bargain collectively, and who delayed and delayed and delayed and delayed and delayed some more before choosing what has been aptly described as "budget terrorism and blackmail."

Enough already. Enough. Layoff notices go out in just a couple of weeks, and it's not just "going to be a disaster for the city of Philadelphia" if the Senate fails to pass the budget, but a disaster for the entire state.

The Daily News and Inquirer keep reporting that a deal is near, but I am less sanguine. So as usual, I encourage you to call your legislators in Harrisburg: you can find your senator here and your representative here. Tell them to save our libraries.

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 7 of 7
Report Violation

1. wendymae said... on Sep 14, 2009 at 09:21AM

“brendan do you have any numbers on how many school kids need the libraries to do their work? i just took a cursory look at the school library directory and only a handful have after school access to computers. quite a few schools have no internet access at all. some have no library at all. most schools have only a handful of computers in the library; looks like 1 per 100 students in most schools. i haven't come across a single one with wheelchair access.

i see also that they rely heavily on public libraries around the state, and i suppose that the entire philly collection will not be available.

nutter really is an idiot for trying this.

Report Violation

2. wendymae said... on Sep 14, 2009 at 09:26AM


have you seen this? report done about the effects on school kids when only some of the libraries were slated for closing.

thanks, now you've got me on a roll brendan!”

Report Violation

3. Julie Fellows said... on Sep 17, 2009 at 01:00AM

“I'm from Salt Lake City Utah I saw this story on line. If your city allows this to happen it will set a precedence for other cities this appalling. Your city and state reps. should try to petition the Feds. for a share of the bail out money that is going to uneeded projects which they know are many. This could be tried as the city tries to work out it's budget issues. Instead of totaly closing or stopping all activites find a way to close one day a week have employees take a turn at taking a day off, there may be many ways to try to keep these very important programs open. If policemen and fireman are laid off and libraries closed it causes great danger to citizens and many people only have the libraries to afford to read, be involved in community or rec. programs or other services. People who already have no other way to afford any activities will be devasted. It does'nt take a rocket scientist to figure out the damage that will be caused to many people. Just another dream stealer .”

Report Violation

4. brendancalling said... on Sep 17, 2009 at 07:04AM

i really hate the way the weekly deletes comments if you forget to enter your email

@julie: it's too late. When Obama released the stimulus funds, specter was still a republican, and cut hundreds of billions from the original amount. PA lost out on $1.6 billion in state recovery funds, which would have almost closed our budget hole.
Maybe if there's a second round, arlen will have wised up but for now everyone suffers.”

Report Violation

5. BookWorm said... on Sep 17, 2009 at 10:50AM

“This is an excellent article. It puts the problem in an economic nutshell that even a squirrel-brained beancounter should be able to understand. Good luck, Philadelphia, from a reader in Seattle.”

Report Violation

6. Lori said... on Sep 17, 2009 at 01:40PM

“I learned of this yesterday and posted about it today on Fermented Fur. As a lifelong library lover, former library employee, and absolute book nerd, I was horrified. Thank you for writing the most comprehensive article I've seen on the situation (also for mentioning that pot should be legal, but that's a whole separate issue)! When I went looking for more information, I was shocked to see how little was out there... and I've been wondering... where's the outrage??? If I were a Philadelphia taxpayer, I'd be beating down somebody's door and demanding answers and a solution to this tragic (and totally unacceptable) situation! I hope the emergency funding is found and secured, because a community without a public library system is too terrible to contemplate.”

Report Violation

7. Marlene Legreaux said... on Sep 18, 2009 at 06:01PM

“Congratulations for your important article!

I really learned about this situation this Monday when I was visiting "The Northeast Regional Library" (2228 Cottman Avenue) with my 4 children.
I was really surprised with this can be possible this in the USA, if the more important part for a strong and organizated Country is all the resources for the education.

I have been very worry with the possibility to close all the Libraries in Philadelphia, because I have been trying to provide more educational support to my children visiting the Library (Monday to Thursday) to do their School Homework with better quality, and to build a good habit for my kids, reading 2 books everyday.

My children are:

* Elvy Abraham (9 years / 4th Grade)
* Elvy Jesus (8 years / 3th Grade)
* Diana Carolina (6 years / 1th Grade)
* Elvy Enmanuel (5 years / Kindergarten)

I think they deserve the right to grow and study with the good service of our Free Library of Philadelphia.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)