Letters to the Editor

Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 2 | Posted Jul. 20, 2011

Share this Story:

Snap Judgment

Regarding last week’s cover story about photographer JD Dragan:

I am black, I am a photographer and I saw the show. The work was banal, stereotypical and derivative. Some Mapplethorpe, some Serrano; it’s all been done before. Just like Michelle Bachman, it proves that white people should probably back up off slavery. You guys just don’t get it. Not then and not now. Slavery is more than a hot button issue to play with to a black man. So some white guy gets off on muscle bound black studs; he gets a show and the cover of the paper. Meanwhile actual black photographers are still excluded. I guess things have not changed all that much, have they?

JAMES MORTON, via email

I had to laugh when I read that someone who knows Dragan was quoted as saying “(His) work is much more subtle and soft” than Robert Mapplethorpe. Was the friend describing the “soft” way a handgun was held over a subject’s taught buttocks, or the “subtle” draping of a noose around the same subject’s muscular back? It’s no wonder Dragan hates being compared to Mapplethorpe. But he must know that his work is only relevant in that it is a poor imitation. Just because there is a lot of dick does not mean it is “edgy,” and just because the artist lives in Philly does not mean he deserves the cover. I can’t decide who is more gimmicky, Dragan or PW.

NICK COOPER, via email

Shop Right

Regarding Aaron Kases news feature on the failure of a Germantown supermarket due to pay-to-play practices:

I don’t know the political angle on the Chelten Plaza project, but my eyebrows rose at the phrase “when grocery stores fail in areas that sorely need them.” I just moved into this neighborhood a couple months ago, but it didn’t take long to discover that there’s a Pathmark at Chelten and Wayne avenues. That’s just one block over from Chelten and Pulaski. I have nothing against another grocery store, but this is hardly an area that “sorely needs” one. If I have any issue with the plan to move the Save-A-Lot, it’s only that C&P would be less convenient than its current location, which is even closer to me than the Pathmark.

ERIC HAMELL, via email

Whether Burns is getting away with pay-to-play murder I couldn’t say, but the loss of the Germantown Fresh Grocer was no great one. I live less than a mile from it; after several visits, I went there only for ice, and usually regretted even that. Dirty, understaffed and rude. The nearby Pathmark isn’t much (if any) better. I go all the way to Andorra or White Marsh for a decent supermarket and I await the opening of the ShopRite at TastyKake’s old property with rapt anticipation.

DENNIS C. McGRATH, via philadelphiaweekly.com

Email Us!

All editorial mail should include your name, address and phone number. Letters may be edited for space and/or clarity.

Letters to the editor: feedback@philadelphiaweekly.com

Calendar listings: listings@philadelphiaweekly.com

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 2 of 2
Report Violation

1. Dont care!! said... on Jul 20, 2011 at 09:21AM

“slaves have jobs and you got a job. according to you they didnt. slavery should be a dead issue in this country. No one alive today was born a slave in this country. no one alive today owned slaves. that guy is a little weird anyway.”

Report Violation

2. Travis Bickle said... on Aug 21, 2011 at 04:56PM

“JD Dragan is nothing more than a talentless pervert getting his rocks off photographing muscular black men. It's a disgrace PW wasted paper on this freako!”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)