Fellowship of the Eagles: a fantasy football epic

Philadelphia fans have no real hope this year. Which is why it’s time for us all to embrace the un-real.

By Max Ufberg
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 7 | Posted Sep. 9, 2013

Share this Story:


In the dictionary, eagle is defined as “any of various large diurnal birds of prey (family Accipitridae) noted for their strength, size, keenness of vision, and powers of flight.”

In classical Greek mythology, the eagle was associated with the northern constellation, Aquila, and was believed to spend its time carrying Zeus’s thunderbolts. (Hey, ask the Greeks, not me.)

And in The Lord of the Rings, it’s the Eagles who pull off an astonishing last-minute save just when things seem utterly bleak.

Why do I know this stuff? Because (1) I don’t have many friends, and (2) I am an Eagles fan.

Through thick and (mostly) thin, I root for the Birds. But, like many other Philadelphians, the very word “eagle” conjures up some rough memories. It’s Todd Pinkston’s crippling fear of getting tackled, it’s Freddie “The People’s Champ” Mitchell’s failed comeback, it’s Nnamdi Asomugha, pretty much every time he stepped onto the field.

(For the record, I also have some good memories as an Eagles fan. There’s Donovan McNabb on 4th and 26, DeSean Jackson’s Miracle at the New Meadowlands, Mike Vick’s one-man demolition of the Redskins during that magical 2010 season.)

These past two years played out like some kind of bad horror movie, with the decline of Mike Vick coinciding with the decline of, well, pretty much everyone else on the Eagles roster. Like every good Philadelphia fan, I’ve kept the faith—but it’s gotten harder and harder to figure out how. Will Chip Kelly’s vaunted offense mask the team’s obvious defensive deficiencies? Will Riley Cooper step up for the injured Jeremy Maclin? Will Vick remember you’re actually supposed to throw the ball to players wearing the same color jersey?

With the team’s immediate future in such dire straits, I’ve been pounding my brain trying to find some sort of silver lining. I can’t. The reality is, this season is looking like a rebuilding year, should this season prove to be a rebuilding year, rather than one of reclamation.

And then it hit me: Reality, for Philadelphia fans, sucks. So let’s leave reality behind. This year, the best way to stay energized about the Eagles is to leap headfirst into the world of fantasy.

Fantasy football offers fans of even the least likely playoff contenders the perfect incentive to turn on the TV on a Sunday afternoon. After all, there’s no team in the NFL that doesn’t have at least a few fantasy assets. (Well, except the Jaguars.) That’s because real-world football success doesn’t always translate into fantasy success—nor do reality-based losses necessarily keep a team’s players from wielding impressive stats on the fantasy grid.

As an example, let’s look at two different quarterbacks, both of whom were injured during part of last year.

  • Player 1: Played 10 games in 2012 season. 1,737 yards, 13 TD, 5 INT, 104.1 QB rating, 132 rush yards.
  • Player 2: Played 10 games in 2012 season. 2,362 yards, 12 TD, 10 INT, 78.1 QB rating, 332 rush yards, 1 rushing TD.

Who looks better? Player 1, right? Not so fast. Player 1, the Chiefs’ Alex Smith, is ranked twenty-fifth among starting quarterbacks on ESPN’s preseason fantasy football rankings. Player 2, Mike Vick, comes in at no. 15. Remember: fantasy firepower isn’t about a player’s surgical efficiency, it’s about their brute-force volume. Mike Vick runs. A lot. (Last year was a down year by all accounts for Vick. For his career, he averages 555 rushing yards per year. Expect him to take off with the ball more this year.) Sure, he might throw two picks—but hey, he’ll also run for 80 yards. Smith, on the other hand, posted a 70.2 completion percentage and guided his then-team to a 6-2-1 record. He’s won more playoff games than Cam Newton, Robert Griffin III, Matt Stafford and Carson Palmer—but in the fantasy world, they all outshine him. Alex Smith isn’t aggressive enough with the football to merit a starting spot in your lineup.

But Vick just might be. Go Eagles! Well—go Eagle.

I refuse to acknowledge this as a lost season. If I have to hyper-localize my fandom at the fantasy level, single player by single player, so be it. Some might call that a delusion. I, however, cite the wisdom of that great coach, Obi-Wan Kenobi: “Many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.”
Fantasy has taken over pop culture these days—and yet if you Google the word, four of the first five results won’t be about Harry Potter or The Hunger Games, they’re about fantasy football. So let’s roll with that this year and just enjoy the Eagles for their pure fantasy value. We’ll treat LeSean McCoy like Katniss Everdeen. Mike Vick like Legolas. Riley Cooper like Professor Snape.

Let’s see what Chapter One has in store…

As our helmet-clad heroes embark on their quest to Mount Fantasy, Vick looks to McCoy and wonders whether his running back will have a bounce-back year, too. Lumbering tight end Brent Celek, already wheezing from the half-mile start to their journey, reminds the group that their Week 1 matchup against the Redskins should provide plenty of opportunities for fantasy greatness—save for the defense, who are likely to feel the wrath of Robert Griffin III & Co. Meanwhile, DeSean Jackson texts pal Snoop Dogg about releasing another rap video.

Who’s Frodo? The guy I want carrying the ring in Week 1: Mike Vick. I know, I talked him up already. But seriously, he’s going up against a Redskins defense that’s ranked 24th going into the first game of the season. Vick has looked sharp for most of the preseason. I don’t see DeAngelo Hall and the Washington secondary posing much of a threat.

Page: 1 2 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 7 of 7
Report Violation

1. Mike Rudolphi said... on Sep 9, 2013 at 02:58PM

“I agree with most of this and I think I can use these tips for my fantasy team. You gotta mention Randall Cunningham. He is one bright spot in a dozen years of misery. Hey, for fantasy, at least the Birds are good for somethin this year. Tired of being disappointed but now I know that at least in my own world, a team from Philly can win some games.”

Report Violation

2. Aviva said... on Sep 9, 2013 at 03:44PM

“A novel way to make Philadelphians feel not so bad about themselves! Go fantasy-realm Iggles!”

Report Violation

3. Joe Portnova said... on Sep 9, 2013 at 08:37PM

“I wish fantasy was around when Rodney Peete was playing. He was short but he could really air it out and was a deceptive scrambler!!”

Report Violation

4. Dovid Rosenberg said... on Sep 9, 2013 at 09:31PM

“Great column, I hope to see it every week. Real life Birds look pretty good tonight too!”

Report Violation

5. Birdwatcher said... on Sep 9, 2013 at 11:59PM

“Fantasy this, Mr. Doom-and-Gloom. Da Boids done skinned Da Skins on Washington's own hallowed ground. What hill is it that you and 10,000 other Phill-idiots think Mike Vick is over again??? Say what????????”

Report Violation

6. Arnold Gass said... on Sep 10, 2013 at 11:24AM

“Get out, booger! The Iggles won't win unless they make Chip get the Kelly out of here and bring back Kotite! Ha, remember that guy? Oh, come on, we're doomed. I have one Bird on my fantasy team: Wolff, but only because I met him once at Sadlacks in Raleigh.”

Report Violation

7. David Robitussin said... on Sep 10, 2013 at 01:30PM

“My parents had the game on at their wash-n-fold laundromat, where I was working late and eating chow mein. And let me tell you, Birds look SOLID baby! Almost made me choke on my stir fry though with that first turnover.

I look forward to your thoughts on putting Vick in my lineup for week 2 vs SD.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)