Feds Say Asian Students' Claims Are Real. Ya Think?

Why does the Philadelphia School District need the feds to tell them what to do?

By Nina Sachdev
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 5 | Posted Aug. 31, 2010

Share this Story:

If it takes a village, the Philadelphia School District is the idiot.

Asian students’ claims of being abused at South Philly High School in December 2009 have merit, according to the Justice Department. The claims are that about 30 Asian students were attacked by a group of mostly black classmates on Dec. 3—and that the district completely botched its handling of the situation. The school district is now being advised by the Justice Department to “take steps to settle the matter.”

If you have children in the school district, or even if you don’t, you should be furious with this latest news. For starters, did the claims lack merit when it was just the students, parents, teachers, civil-rights advocates, politicians and various other concerned citizens making them? Now that there’s a report, something must be done!

And those steps needed to “settle the matter”—they are the same ones that should have been taken years ago at the urging of students, parents, teachers, civil-rights advocates, politicians and various other concerned citizens, correct? Now that there’s a report, something must be done! It wasn’t enough that an Asian civil-rights group complained over and over again!

The district could have done something a year ago when a string of violent incidents in the school was revealed.

PW published a cover story (“Aggregated Assault: Asian Students Seeks Refuge From School Violence”) in September 2009—four months before the attacks—detailing a crisis at South Philly High School.

Further, we wrote about a district-wide crisis:

The litany of abuses isn’t limited to South Philly High. Male and female Asian students—especially those new to the country, who speak little or fractured English—have been targeted over the past few years in schools from the Northeast to South Philly, in elementary and high schools. Students and activists say that Chinese, Vietnamese, Cambodian, Pakistani and other Asian youth have been singled out, assaulted in cafeterias, hallways, on city streets, schools buses and everywhere inbetween.

Still, for some reason, and despite years of violence in the school district and various reports on that violence, the focus is on this one day, Dec. 3. The media are partly to blame for that, with quotes like: “Today’s news fuels charges that what happened on December 3 was no isolated incident but instead symptomatic of more deeply-rooted racial injustice at the school.”

Of course it wasn’t an isolated incident.

And it certainly was not the beginning of school violence in Philadelphia. South Philly High had been on the state’s “persistently dangerous schools” list for three years in a row when that cover story was written. But even that was not the beginning. Far from it.

It wasn’t the beginning in December 2008, either, when Pa.’s State Auditor General Jack Wagner reported that the state Department of Education failed to ensure safety in schools. State officials failed to check the accuracy of school-violence statistics, the report said. Talk about leading by example. Maybe that’s why the school district allegedly got away with misreporting violent incidents, or not reporting them at all. In 2007, the nurse for Tilden Middle School in Southwest Philly sued the district, claiming he was retaliated against for complaining that the number of violent incidents reported didn’t match the number of students’ injuries he was treating.

A search through commissioned reports, studies and newspaper archives reveals hundreds of cases involving student violence. So it’s hard to say when the Philadelphia School District lost control of its rapidly deteriorating student relations. Maybe they never had it. But for years, they’ve been getting away with what they’re doing. Rather, not doing.

Here’s what can be fixed: The rules. First, make some. Then, follow them. If people—students, teachers or officials—break them, respond swiftly. Repeat.

Next, try treating every student equally. Novel idea. If this is done, people can stop talking about school violence as it pertains to race. No one is disputing that Asian students in Philly have been victims of racial injustice. But saying race is the cause assigns a whole lot of blame to the students and very little to the district—which is evident when Superintendent Arlene Ackerman says she is “certainly willing and anxious” to bring these issues to a close. That’s another way of saying: “Hey, I just work here.”

District officials acknowledged a year ago that they did not handle Asians’ complaints properly. So at this point, it’s safe to assume that the school district needs the feds to tell it what to do. This is not a bad thing, if it restores order within our schools. But government-mandated change means that the village idiot has got a lot of homework to do.

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 5 of 5
Report Violation

1. Anonymous said... on Sep 1, 2010 at 10:57AM

“Why is it only White on Black Violance is considered a hate crime. These students are obviously being singled out because of their race.”

Report Violation

2. cn2004 said... on Sep 1, 2010 at 12:28PM

“Why doesn't the writer of this article have the guts to come right and say what everyone knows: the only reason that nothing was done over the years was because everyone is scared at being called a racist. If black students were the victims and whites were the abusers, you can bet every elected politician, every news outlet, and every civil rights organization in the city of Philadelphia would have been out on day one condemning it and calling for everything from a commission to investigate to criminal charges pressed against everyone involved. It's a disgrace that these Asian kids have been brutalized and scarred by their fellow students, but a bigger disgrace is that because of political correctness, nothing was done to prevent or deal with it.”

Report Violation

3. Janice said... on Sep 2, 2010 at 12:33AM

“Its not considered a hate crime because the school district, the city, even the U.S. does not prosecute hate crimes against anyone unless the crime has been against black people. The DOJ dropped the charges against the Black Panthers in Philadelphia and according to the whistle blower lawyer from the DOJ who resigned due to the Obama administration dropping the charges, the DOJ has no interest in prosecuting hate crimes against black people. These students who were harrassing the asian students should be indicted for hate crimes. Where is good ol Al Sharpton. If the students were black, he would be having a rally in the streets of Philadelphia. Al, Jesse and the NAACP are the real racists of America.”

Report Violation

4. kevin said... on Sep 5, 2010 at 08:06PM

“We're closing down libraries and Arlene Ackerman makes $360,000 a year. We're closing down fire houses and Carl Green makes $302,000 a year. Where is your priorities Philadelphia ? You turn your backs on these poor Asian kids who just want to learn.”

Report Violation

5. Anonymous said... on Sep 7, 2010 at 03:13PM

“These asian students have been thrown into a den of savages for years with no hope of protection from these feral humans. Because these predators are "one of their own" among city school administration, they don't want these asian students to accomplish in a few years what "their own" can't seem to accomplish in a lifetime, that being civil & educated behavior that enables them to contribute instead of drain from our society.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Asian Students Under Assault
By G.W. Miller III

Community organizers say 30 or more Asian students were attacked Thursday at South Philadelphia High School. In September, PW's George Miller wrote this cover story about how Asian students are regularly targeted in Philadelphia schools.

RELATED: Asian Students Protest Interracial Violence Breakdance Boys in South Philly