Why the Gayborhood Vote Is So Important to the 182nd District

State Rep. Babette Josephs' electoral success has long been bound up with the rainbow vote. This year, her challenger, Brian Sims, is openly gay.

By Tara Murtha
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 8 | Posted Apr. 18, 2012

Share this Story:

The hottest race in the city for a seat in the state Legislature is going down in the 182nd District, which comprises a chunk of Center City, Logan Square and sections of Fairmount, Washington Square West, Bella Vista, Gray’s Ferry and—where the campaign rhetoric is at its most intense—the Gayborhood.

The incumbent, 71-year-old Babette Josephs, has represented the district for 27 years. Often spotted walking around town with her signature backpack, Josephs is the senior female Democrat in the House, minority chair of the State Government Committee, co-founder of the LGBT caucus and convener of the Women’s Caucus. She’s well-known as a feisty rabble-rouser for progressive issues such as LGBT civil rights and women’s reproductive freedom. Fans—and “the lady from Philadelphia,” as they call her on the House floor, definitely has fans, not just constituents—praise Josephs for the colorful prose she employs while delivering impassioned speeches on the floor.

With female politicians making up only 17 percent of the Legislature—more than half of whom are Republicans—Josephs regularly reams out conservative legislators over feminist issues. Recently, she called the Republican women in Legislature—which ranks 42nd for gender equality—who voted for the controversial mandatory-ultrasound bill “men with breasts,” which pissed off a few people, and was called “a sour note” by the website PoliticsPA.

Joseph’s electoral success has long been bound up with the district’s rainbow vote. The 182nd has the highest number of LGBT residents of any district in the state; that fact is so important to any election there that in 2010, Josephs made national headlines for accusing challenger Gregg Kravitz, who publicly identified as bisexual, of being a closet heterosexual pandering for the LBGT vote. Kravitz lost—but not by much, scoring 39 percent of the vote.

That bodes for a tight race with this year’s challenger, 33-year-old policy attorney Brian Sims, one of five openly gay candidates currently running to become one of the first openly gay legislators in Pennsylvania history. While he’s a first-time political candidate, Sims has some interesting experience despite being less than half of Josephs’ age. He’s done stints as president of the LGBT nonprofit advocacy organization Equality PA, lawyer for the Bar Association, and treasurer of Joseph’s 2010 campaign, before he broke with her to run for her seat himself.

Unsurprisingly, that political apostasy has greatly defined the shape of the race between them.“What’s the real difference between [Sims’] stance and positions and mine?” asks Josephs. “When I hear him talk or look at his mailings, it looks like he took them off of our website. This man has no real reason to be dissatisfied with me.”Indeed, there are no fundamental policy differences to debate in this race; both candidates are progressives. They’re both pro-choice, concerned with LGBT civil rights, against school vouchers, and for green jobs. Sure, they have a couple minor disagreements: Sims vocally favors a city sex-offender registry while Joseph cites studies showing that they’re ineffective. Sims favors a bill to reduce the size of the Legislature while Josephs points out that it doesn’t reduce the cost of the Legislature. But ultimately, Sims casts the major distinction as one of political effectiveness. “I, like most people, knew [Josephs] by reputation” before going to work for her, he says, “and I liked that we were sending this tough woman to Harrisburg to talk about all these issues. What I didn’t know is that being aggressive can get you pretty far—if your aggression is tempered by integrity and you’re effective.”

He says Josephs is “statistically, mathematically incapable” of passing legislation: “She hasn’t passed legislation where she is the primary sponsor since 1996,” says Sims, arguing that calling Republican women “men with breasts” doesn’t help you get votes. “Believing the right things makes you a progressive but … it’s the job to move forward the political ideology agenda, not just be a billboard for them.”

Of course, sponsoring one’s own bills isn’t the only measure—or even the primary measure—of a legislator’s effectiveness, particularly a senior legislator who holds leadership roles. “My opponent has taken a very mechanistic and bean counter, cruncher kind of approach,” says the Representative. Josephs points to accomplishments such as helping increase the number of minority, women and veteran-owned business contracts with the Department of General Services and procuring grants for small businesses in her district as accomplishments that did not require passing a bill.

Coffee-shop talk about the race has been largely philosophical, asking whether it’s better to vote for a seasoned, hardcore woman, or the gay newcomer. District resident Chris Pinto calls Josephs “a pro-female, pro-choice, pro-GLBTQ candidate—and that’s a good representation of the district,” acknowledging that openly LGBT elected officials are indeed hugely important, “but we keep cutting off our feet and then try to run a marathon, and it never works. Of all the seats [for Sims] to try and get, why this one? Why take on the one person who's been fighting for us before he was even born?”

One longtime Josephs supporter, an elderly gent who’s decided to vote instead for Sims this year and requested anonymity, suggests: “She has been very effective in past representation, but it appears that she’s lost a certain amount of prestige on the floor in Harrisburg. I think that Brian Sims is going to bring a fresh approach … it’s hard for us in the gay community, because she’s been such a vocal and avid supporter, and I believe many of us … appreciate that.” He adds: “The one disadvantage that youth has when looking at politics is they try to be too politically correct. I’m sure if you talk to men under a certain age, none are going to bring up the fact that a male in Harrisburg can be much more effective than any female.”

Josephs is dismissive of the idea that Sims represents a more pragmatic approach, that he’d be able to get more done in Harrisburg with a can-do, cooperative attitude. “We don’t get a vote from a Republican unless you give a vote to a Republican,” she says. “What issue is Brian Sims willing to compromise to work with Republicans? I don’t compromise any Philadelphia issues, any poverty issues, any civil rights issues… What is he going to give up, whose civil rights is he going to give away, when he reaches across the aisle and compromises himself with Republicans?”

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 8 of 8
Report Violation

1. Anonymous said... on Apr 18, 2012 at 10:09PM

“Josephs has been a rep for 27 years!? WTF! Where's LGBT non-discrimination laws then?? Where's an anti-bullying bill?? What has she been doin for 27 years????”

Report Violation

2. Steve said... on Apr 18, 2012 at 10:21PM

“I don't know if Sims will be more effective than Josephs but I'm willing to give him a shot. Josephs is good at constituent services but I want a legislator who will try to pass bills on areas of agreement with more conservative members of the legislature. I also liked his stance on business taxes which leads me to believe he understands that for Pennsylvania to provide progressive services that many of us want that we need to encourage business and residents so we have a tax base to do it.”

Report Violation

3. Anonymous said... on Apr 19, 2012 at 09:44AM

“Anyone who assails Rep. Josephs for not passing volumes of progressive legislation demonstrates a fundamental lack of understanding of the politics of Harrisburg. We don't just have a conservative legislature; we have a conservative legislature with a huge Republican majority. Getting new bills passed that do not fit within their narrow agenda is virtually impossible, and using that as the yardstick by which one measures Babette's effectiveness is a false and useless construct. What people should look at is how effective she has been building coalitions to stop the worst impulses of the Republicans, to block bills that would strip people of rights or impose draconian new demands. She can't win every one of these battles, but nobody fights more fiercely to protect hard won rights for women, workers, and the LGBT community. In Harrisburg, a feisty, efffective protector is exactly who we need - not someone who intends to go work with Republicans who stand for everything we're against”

Report Violation

4. Matt Goldfine said... on Apr 19, 2012 at 11:01AM

“The Brian Sims campaign complete disagrees with the sexist comment that men are much more effective than any female in Harrisburg and condemns this comment. It is an insult to women in and outside of the legislature, and the men who are working to ensure that the old boys clubs that have ruled our political systems are dissolved. It is not politically correctness that stops one from saying things like this, as this unnamed commenter suggests, it's the fact that there are strong, effective women who are proving it wrong everyday. This campaign is about the future, not about dwelling in old social norms, and whoever this unnamed commenter is, they in no way represent what either campaign in this race is about. Good riddance to old conceptions and misogynist political systems. -Matt Goldfine, Campaign Manager, Brian Sims for State Representative”

Report Violation

5. Kathleen said... on Apr 22, 2012 at 04:37PM

“It is long past the time to replace career politician Babette Josephs with a statesman who will, hopefully, conduct himself with the dignify we should expect of an elected official.

Ms. Josephs, unfortunately, embodies all that is wrong with those who serve as examples for term limits: brash, coarse, hostile, disrespectful, and an always exhibited sense of entitlement.”

Report Violation

6. Reyn said... on Apr 24, 2012 at 11:42AM

“@Kathleen -- and you manage in two paragraphs where you are trying not to to STILL identify yourself as a conservative by using the words "sense of entitlement."

Am I wrong? If I'm right, should you be in this discussion?


Report Violation

7. Anonymous said... on Apr 26, 2012 at 05:56PM

“I'm not in PA but found the Sims story fascinating. He seems to have gobbled up every challenge he's come across. He's obviously smart, perfectly educated for the job, and evidently has transcendent personal relationship skills. It will be interesting to see how he does when he descends into the pit of vipers that is the current PA legislature.

It IS a shame that his success comes at the expense of such a dedicated and colorful character as Babette Josephs.

Mr Sims would do well to find some way to keep her involved.

I'm jealous that I don't live in such a place. My district in Ohio has Republicans so deeply intrenched in both the Ohio House and US House that Democrats put up either a sacrificial lamb or no lamb at all against them.

Kinda like you place, only backwards.

Help!! I'm going down for the third time!!

Don't forget how important an Obama win in PA is.

I know, I know, I'm ashamed to be an Ohioan after 2000 and 2004.

I'm working on it.


Report Violation

8. Eugene said... on Apr 27, 2012 at 03:55PM

“She certainly was good at constituent services. She was visible and accessible, not just at greenfest / community groups / civics, but hosted events of her own (in support of public schools most recently), and would go door-to-door for years introducing herself. As for legislative effectiveness -- it's hard for us to tell. Perhaps her years of experience against a conservative legislature have disillusioned her towards compromises. She certainly was already fully supportive of all the same local causes on which Rep Sims campaigned. Hopefully his hallmark is that he will simply be more effective.”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Why You Should Care About These Primary Challenges
By Michael Alan Goldberg

From hot dog vendor to Pennsylvania state senator to ex-con to Philly mayoral challenger to ... Harrisburg again? It could happen, if ever-tenacious 72-year-old Milton Street claims victory in this odd race to fill the state House seat—encompassing a wide swath of North Philly—which Jewell Williams vacated last year to successfully run for Philadelphia sheriff.

Related Content

Attorney General Candidates Patrick Murphy and Kathleen Kane Battle in the Democratic Primary
By Michael Alan Goldberg

Heading into November, yet another formidable Republican—no-nonsense Cumberland County District Attorney David Freed, who’s running unopposed in next week’s primary—will try to make mincemeat out of either Kathleen Kane or Patrick Murphy, the two Democrats sparring fiercely in a primary bout to determine who’ll carry their party’s flag in the AG race this fall.

Related Content

The Rise and Fall, Again, of Rick Santorum's Political Ambition
By Randy LoBasso

Everyone remembers the photo from 2006, when Rick Santorum had to stand up and acknowledge he’d been voted out of the U.S. Senate by the people of Pennsylvania. While Santorum spoke, his 8-year-old daughter Sarah Maria stood next to him, her chubby cheeks soaked with tears. It was the picture of the end of the Republican Revolution that, for a decade, had ruled Congress, and thus Washington, and thus America.