Philly's Homeless Struggle to Get IDs Under the New Voter Law

By Randy LoBasso
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 5 | Posted Aug. 8, 2012

Share this Story:

More than 100 people stand in one of two lines across the street from Family Court at 19th and Vine streets. Most of them are homeless. Some of them are there to receive a free meal from the few volunteers set up near the courthouse. On the other side of the lawn, toward the Ben Franklin Parkway, there’s a group congregated around a man wearing a red Philadelphia Kixx T-shirt, holding a clipboard. He’s Adam Bruckner, and he’s been coming here with the goal of getting the homeless IDs for the past 10 years.

“Years ago, I used to ask homeless guys, ‘Why don’t you get a job?’” says Bruckner, after he signs a $13.50 check and hands it to a tall, bearded man who just proved his identity by showing two prescription drug bottles bearing his name. “And they said, ‘It’s because we can’t get IDs.’”

So Bruckner, 37, decided to help. When he started out, he was just a young guy with a clipboard who gave money out of his own pocket. But within weeks, he said, word spread that there was someone in Philadelphia looking to get poor and homeless people identification so they could get jobs, cash checks and vote. Hundreds of people began coming to him every Monday at the Vine Street location. Today, the Parkway meet-up is a charitable nonprofit called Philly Restart operating with $60,000—most of which is spent in the form of checks written for $13.50, the amount required to get a state ID from PennDOT.

“Now, many of the shelters and halfway houses in the city will refer their clients straight here,” he says, adding that he sees hundreds of people each week, and there is no universal story of the types of people who need IDs.

With all the talk about the working poor and elderly being denied access to the polls due to the new voter-ID law, the homeless have been almost universally ignored in the debate. When Philadelphia Weekly first reported on this issue in June 2011, we noted that Project H.O.M.E. objected to the bill, saying it put up major roadblocks for those who were rebuilding their lives and had the eventual goal of obtaining an ID. Since then, of course, the law has passed, and the debate over its necessity, its usefulness and its legality is stronger than ever.

Bruckner notes how excited he was when he first heard about the bill. “I thought maybe that would help take care of some things,” he says, “but it’s made things more complicated … it seems like there’s this big miscommunication about who could get [identification] and when they could get it … it hasn’t dropped my numbers at all.”

And he has no way of knowing how many people he’s seen have, or even need ID. Usually, he says he recognizes only a couple faces in the crowd, and only knows one person, Tyson (the first homeless man he helped), by name. The rest, he says, are first-timers.

One man, wearing a white undershirt and white sneakers, says Bruckner has already helped him get a birth certificate, but isn’t sure about his next step. “I was locked up [in prison] for five years,” says the man, who did not give his name. “[And when I got out], they don’t tell you that you need a new ID when you get out … the jail is overcrowded and basically they got nowhere to put people, it’s bullshit.” He says he needs an ID for “a job, voting, all that.”

Another man, skinny, bearded and with acne scars dotting his face, says he doesn’t have a referral letter because he can’t get into the methadone clinic at 8th Street and Girard Avenue. He gives Bruckner a pill bottle to prove his name; Bruckner signs a check for $13.50 and sends him on his way.

“Either [the people here] never had [identification], or they’re in a high-risk situation where they live in a shelter and you go to the bathroom and your stuff gets stolen. Or you’re in jail and [they lose their things upon getting released],” Bruckner says, adding that, for the homeless population, holding on to IDs—expired or nonexpired—can be very difficult. And Pennsylvania law does not allow people to acquire a new copy of their previously issued ID unless they have documentation backing up who they are—and many who lose their ID or have had it stolen can’t.

“We think because there are 250 people sleeping on the streets of Philadelphia, then there are 250 homeless people living in Philadelphia,” Bruckner says. “That’s totally erroneous. If you consider the shelters, the numbers in rehab, halfway houses, the number goes into the thousands really easily,” he says. “If the problem were as easy as 250 people on the Parkway, you could open a 300-bed place and end homelessness. That’s not the way it is. So it’s the same thing with the ID. It’s not like you can get these 250 people an ID and say everyone has an ID. It’s literally thousands and thousands of people every year.”

Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 5 of 5
Report Violation

1. Jordan Gwendolyn Davis said... on Aug 8, 2012 at 12:24PM

“The good news is, for those who hold driver's licenses, if you remember your license number, you can always get a new copy without any other secondary identification. However, for those who have non-driver IDs, it may be more difficult.

And believe me, some people would rather live out on the streets than go into the shelter system, I know I was one of them.”

Report Violation

2. Anonymous said... on Aug 9, 2012 at 05:53PM

“‎"How much will it cost me to get a Photo Identification Card in order to vote?

Nothing. It’s free. (But getting a certified copy of your birth certificate will cost you $10 if you were born in Pennsylvania or more if you were born elsewhere.)"”

Report Violation

3. Vinny said... on Sep 7, 2014 at 08:40PM

“I have two homeless men I am trying to help get back on their feet. Both men are former military, whose worlds fell apart around them. One, we'll call J, is a very hard worker who has a job but because he has no ID he can't be brought on full time. He does know his SSN but I don't know where to begin in helping him get IDs. The second gentleman, we'll call S, does not seem to remember much if his past, has a definite alcohol issue and isn't really resourceful to meet his own physical needs. Please, my heart breaks for them and many others I know and get the privilege to spend time with. If you can help me help them, I am willing to do what I can to help.”

Report Violation

4. Heather said... on Dec 9, 2014 at 03:04PM

“That is bs I can't do nothing with out I'd I'm 28 get as I and can't get my check unless I got Id I have nothing but my ss card what can I do”

Report Violation

5. Marcel said... on Nov 13, 2015 at 10:49PM

“That was then this is now the price for ids whent up is a he still going to be writing these checks for people now that it's $30.00 ?”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Picture Imperfect: PA Bill Would Require Photo ID at the Polls
By Randy LoBasso

State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe says he’s doing it for the patriots among us. This, he says, is why House Bill 934—the Pennsylvania Voter Identification Protection Act, which requires all Keystone State citizens to show ID at their respective polling places—needs to pass.