Is Philly's Animal Control Finally Under Control?

By Tara Murtha
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 32 | Posted Mar. 28, 2012

Share this Story:

“We’re still focusing on working with the Animal Care & Control Team,” says Marc Peralta, the PSPCA’s COO, who is functioning as interim CEO as the group conducts a national search for a permanent replacement. “I obviously have a great working relationship with Sue, and with PAWS as well.”

PAWS’ Levy agrees. “We certainly have a long way to go in this city, and the population of animals that are in danger hasn’t diminished,” she says. “But the landscape has improved greatly and so there’s a true air of collaboration … we realize that each agency plays a different role, but they are all in this together.”

Even Garrett Elwood, founder of Citizens for a No-Kill Philadelphia, who has been vocally critical of both the PSPCA and the city, is positive about the new structure. “We’re almost back to where we were before [2009], before the city screwed up. We’re in a better place. We have a stronger foundation now,” says Elwood. He pauses, then laughs. “It’s weird.”

Prev| Page: 1 2
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 32 of 32
Report Violation

1. Anonymous said... on Mar 28, 2012 at 10:55PM

“Sue Cosby is more of the same. I am very discouraged for her to be the director of ACCT. "Nothing changes if nothing changes"”

Report Violation

2. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 05:22AM

“Please Sue, no more of your $1 cat sales. Last season I found three microchipped cats who had been adopted during these sales. One owner was nowhere to be found. The other two said they didn't want the cats back--one because he was sick, the other because "he might have fleas" and she was unwilling to pay for a few doses of Advantage. I surely understand the challenges when you have so many cats and kittens flying through the door, but cats shouldn't go to these sub par homes for $1 a piece.”

Report Violation

3. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 06:50AM

“Their policies are absolutely the worst. In the last 18 months I've fostered a kitty that, after a dozen "vet" visits (you see a vet tech, never a vet) I adopted the kitty and took her to MY vet, was diagnosed with feline asthma, NOT a URI AND when we adopted a dog, he had to be returned within 24 hours because he had bloody stool POURING out of him and could barely stand up. He was also cat aggressive after we were told he was cat tested. (we have four cats) The staff of ACCT is rude, ignorant and not at all helpful.”

Report Violation

4. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 07:35AM

“Who is making these decisions over at the ACCT? I mean its obvious that they don't care about animals. Who is on this board that seems more preoccupied with putting the same old crew in the same old positions, rather then fixing the problems that everyone who deals with ACCT is aware of. Sick animals, sub par management, disgruntled employees, and inadequate services and a return CEO making more the 100,000 bucks a year? The city once again shows its lackadaisical attitude in serving the residents of this city. As the first comment said: "more of the same".”

Report Violation

5. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 08:59AM

“Disagree with all of the above posts. Everyone I've ever encountered at ACCT works as hard as they can with the resources they have....who would be smiling and chipper every day when their job is to take in animals that nobody wants and do their best to re-home them and save them from being euthanized? The volunteers are the best you'll find anywhere. I too have adopted a sick dog from ACCT during a canine flu outbreak - it took a couple of weeks and some extra TLC to get her better, but she recovered and is the BEST dog ever! I say, good luck Sue! And by the way....$100,000 is not a lot of money for a CEO...even of a non-profit.”

Report Violation

6. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 09:08AM

“As an ACCT employee, I find it very disrespectful to say that we do not care about the animals. We love animals and we try our best under our current policy to help the animals at the shelter. We have an awesome volunteer group who are here at the shelter from 8 am to almost 10 pm everyday walking dogs, training dogs, working with cats. As the only public intake shelter for the entire city, we have more animals coming in daily than we have them leaving the shelter. Of course we would like to save every animal but unfortunately we can't. To paint a picture last year in July, we took in 2308 cats. That's just July alone. Now I would agree that the policies need to be reformed as well as the board. This job isn't the easiest between dealing with phones ringing non stop, customer's at your window, and entering paperwork. If you think you can do this job, feel free to just sit here and observe just two hours in the shelter and see what exactly we see.”

Report Violation

7. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 01:29PM

“I am a new employee and upon my hire I was amazed at all the services that ACCT offers at no or little cost to the residents of Philadelphia. The people that work there border on being fanatical about their commitment to the animals which they serve. And make it clear, they feel as though they serve as the voice of animals which cannot speak for themselves. It is easy to criticize the organization upon first site of a frustrated employee. However how many tooth baring grins are you going to have when you have just told a person that their sick animal is probably going to be put down, or dealing with a person with a dead animal which they have had for years. Emotionally this job has me involved more with people's needs then any of my 15 years of non for profit experience ever has. I am not involved with the political aspect of the job, and truthfully I have very little interest in what goes on behind the scenes. I am here to SERVE their needs and nothing more.”

Report Violation

8. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 03:34PM

“As an ACCT volunteer for over 2 years I have seen wonderful improvements during my time there. This has been due to the staff and volunteers. The pen pal program, Dog Behavior team, Cat behavior team and adoption events have done more to save these animals than any of the policy makers that claim to be responsible for the improvements. To hear the quote above from Sue Cosby that
“Humane societies were created to protect animals, and animal control [agencies] in municipalities were created to protect people from bad animals. Animal control didn’t fit in with the mission of PSPCA.” is very surprising for me to hear. There are NO bad animals at ACCT. Only animals who have been abandoned by thier careless owners. Each and every animal I have ever been in contact with at the shelter has been starved for love and attention. I have fostered over 15 animals and adopted both a dog and a cat from ACCT and not a single one of them is "bad". They have all been amazing.”

Report Violation

9. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 03:42PM

“As for the person who mentioned about the 'cat test. Cat testing at ACCT consists of bringing the dog into the cat room where all the cats are in cages to see how the dog might react upon seeing and smelling the cats.It is by no means the best system, but is the safest for the cats. It can be very difficult to get an accurate read on any animals behavior in a shelter environment. It is a loud, scary, unfamiliar place. This is why the amazing adoptions counselors provide every adopter with resouces such as contact information for the dog and cat behavior teams so that you can talk to them about how to properly introduce your new animal into the home. They are an amazing group of volunteers who have fostered hundreds of animals between them and can offer great advice on your new pets behavior issues. It is up to the adopter to take advantage of the education and resources that they can provide. You can't expect the animal to know what to do in a brand new environment!”

Report Violation

10. Anonymous said... on Mar 29, 2012 at 04:57PM

“I posts about the $1 cat sales above and wanted to add that I've had wonderful experiences with the life saving department and volunteers. They work VERY hard to place animals nobody else wants and do so with few resources. I do, however, wish there could be a bigger change at the top.”

Report Violation

11. Anonymous said... on Mar 30, 2012 at 08:43PM

“The Truth About Free Cat Adoptions”

Report Violation

12. anonymous said... on Apr 3, 2012 at 08:12AM

“The main problem that the employee's of ACCT encounter everyday, are the careless, and mindless pet owners or customers. Whoever have a negative comment to make about the employee's, need to be an employee for just one day to see first hand, the neglect of people to their animals.”

Report Violation

13. Anonymous said... on Apr 3, 2012 at 10:09AM


Report Violation

14. Anonymous said... on Apr 6, 2012 at 07:24AM

“Cosby is involved with Nathan Winograd and Rick Berman. They support puppy mills and hoarders and also the breeders that help create the overpopulation problem. Looks like the animals of Philly are going to suffer again!”

Report Violation

15. ExposingTheNKAgenda said... on Apr 9, 2012 at 08:19AM

“BINGO Comment #14 - all this club of NK is going to do is work to change/eliminate our city's HUMANE animal ordinances. This is happening nationwide in animal controls and humane societies.

Biggest red flag is the massive amounts of dog breeders who buy and recommend the NK "tour" machine's book -Redemption. In fact, Google his name, the book name and "Akc dog breeder" and get comfy.

They are being exposed slowly but surely - thank GOD.”

Report Violation

16. ExposingTheNKAgenda said... on Apr 9, 2012 at 08:23AM

“For detailed exposure of this "agenda", visit this website:

Whoever does that blog reports on it all across the nation - not just in one state.”

Report Violation

17. Joyce Oxfeld said... on Apr 10, 2012 at 06:40PM

“ACCT Philly is not a holding area for 'bad', dogs. Many more things, have I observed as a volunteer have been happening here. Cats and Dogs who are frightened and/or have been abused are socialized. Illnesses that could kill or lower the chance for adoption are treated. Injuries are treated. Orphaned Kittens are nursed. Dogs have the the Pen Pal program to get intensive attention, training and exposure to help with foster or adoption. Big dogs are given exercise from their pens. All dogs. Foster and Adoption Parents are screened. The Hunting Park facility is Hugh. They never turn an animal away 24/7. They work tireless to save and place each animal possible.”

Report Violation

18. Current Volunteer said... on Apr 15, 2012 at 07:38PM

“Maybe someone should ask why the dog behaviorist was fired last year for animal abuse and then reinstated. As of April 1 he was promoted to shelter manager and is still dating a volunteer who is one of the leads for the Dog Behavior Team. I'm thinking things are going back to the way they were with nepotism taking hold quite well. I also hear that some of the staff has made harsh comments to volunteers on Facebook and nothing has been done to those employees. I'm sure it will blow up in their faces once again.”

Report Violation

19. Frustrated... said... on Apr 24, 2012 at 12:56PM

“First of all, about ACCT employees being rude, unfortunately sometimes yes our emotions do get the best of us. No it's not fair to the customers who are there with good intentions but after seeing abused, neglected and dying animals walking through our doors day after day with excuses from owners like "we just don't want him anymore" or worse, finding an animal that was abandoned by their owner and left to fend for themselves on the street and then having 5 people call screaming that there is a dog running loose on their block...we can only take so much. Our vet techs have to put countless animals to sleep everyday because some people (who should have never owned a pet to begin with) just don't care. We take the thought of sadness and death home with us everyday because that is what we see. It's an emotionally challenging job that most people could never do, anyone who disagrees should come and sit in our lobby for a few hours one day and just listen to the things we hear.”

Report Violation

20. Frustrated... said... on Apr 24, 2012 at 12:58PM

“continued: Our animal control officers who patrol the city picking up stray and unwanted pets from owners who can't even be bothered to bring their animal in themselves are driving around in vehicles that break down on a regular basis. City residents don't want to hear that there is only so much we can do when we receive hundreds of calls a day from people needing our help on top of investigating complaints. They don't want to hear that our officers are on another emergency and will be there as soon as possible, no that's not the residents fault but it isn't the employees either. There really is only so much we can do, Philadelphia is a big city with a lot of people living in it. Please be patient with us and we will do our very best to help you. The day to day employees you see everyday have nothing to do with making the policy's we only have to follow them. Most of us are there simply because we care about animals and want to help, I personally am there for no other reason”

Report Violation

21. Frustrated... said... on Apr 24, 2012 at 01:02PM

“@"Current Volunteer" - you really should do your homework and make sure your facts are straight before making a post like that. If you are so unhappy with the way things are being run then why do you volunteer with us.
We do our best to work hand and hand with the volunteers but it's not always easy. And yes I'm sure that goes both ways. The volunteers are very important to the animals in the shelter and without them a lot more lives would be even worse. Please consider making positive suggestions to the volunteer coordinator instead.”

Report Violation

22. Anonymous said... on May 8, 2012 at 08:19PM

“@Current Volunteer you clearly don't know your facts. I am a current employee who was here when it happened (not that it's any of yours or anyone's business). The last time I checked this is an animal shelter and that manager who you are referring too is a DAMN GOOD MANAGER/BEHAVIORIST. The last time I checked, you're a volunteer, just that a volunteer meaning do what you're supposed to do. And that is work with the animals not to sit here and gossip or put another persons business on front street. To be honest you need not volunteer here anymore if you are more concerned with another human being's personal life. Here's an idea, how about you get a life. Or better yet, why don't you and your little buddies (THIS DOES NOT APPLY ALL ONLY SOME VOLUNTEERS) who have a secret facebook page discussing or talking about the employees here at acct....its funny we have a meeting tomorrow and I think i will bring this up.”

Report Violation

23. Jamielynn said... on May 16, 2012 at 11:46AM

“I will not post anonymously. I am an active volunteer & foster home for the shelter. I respect the job that many of the staff do at the shelter & the volunteers. I found this post accidentally while googling to find an email address at ACCT. As to #18 's comments I would be curious to see your facts backing up that animal abuse occurred & if that is the case it absolutely should be reported if someone was abusing animals. However I have a feeling the post may be based all on hearsay & gossip & is out of line.
As to comment #22-25 I find it offensive & disappointing to read that a staff member would make this comment: "youre a volunteer, just that a volunteer meaning do what you're supposed to do". What does that even mean? The volunteers at ACCT go far above & beyond just working with the animals- we are right there in the trenches of it too. It's a shame you posted anonymously-now we just have to wonder which of the ACCT staff have such an attitude towards "just volunteers"”

Report Violation

24. Anonymous said... on May 18, 2012 at 11:18PM

“First there are no behaviorists or certified dog trainers at their facility. Second seeing the comment from an employee it's pretty clear how they feel about their volunteers. What a shame for those animals that nothing will change while the current regime is in control no matter how hard the well meaning volunteers try. So to the volunteers-why try and help where you are not wanted?”

Report Violation

25. Anonymous said... on May 19, 2012 at 03:45PM

“The solution of the problem is not keeping the old one. The PSPCA was not doing a good job overseeing the animal control for the city, so they bring in the same person who was head of the PSPCA to run the animal control now. Nothing yet has changed. You still see the same old Pspca run animal control under a new name. The same broken trucks, just with duct-tape on them now. The same broken building. The same broken management, just shuffled around. What has changed?

As for the volunteers vs the employees there. The volunteers for the most part act like they run the place. I've seen some belittle the employees to their faces and behind thier backs. Don't get me wrong, some of the volunteers are kind and sweet people. Others seem to feel like they are so much better then they petty people who work at animal control.

As for the employees, I feel bad for them. The place gained a new name, but just gained a new polished terd. They are always shorthanded, overworked, and ill-equipped. Atleast once a month you see one of their trucks broken down or baing towed somewhere. The office staff running to other rooms to get something they printed because the printer available to them is broken.

When will this change? When this incarnation fails and the city chooses to go back to the PSPCA?”

Report Violation

26. Anonymous said... on Jun 17, 2012 at 10:27AM

“I am so saddened by the things I am reading. ACCT does a ton. Is it perfect? No. Human beings are flawed, from the volunteers to the paid staff, to the "owners" who come in all day long surrendering their animals because "she is rude" (as I read on a cat card once!).

Sniping at each other clearly is not helpful. The reality is that the building is not big enough; there is not enough staff, and there are too many animals. The trashy obsession with breeding pit bulls as "fighting" dogs or "guard" dogs exacerbates our problem, as do the idiots who surrender their pregnant mom cats because "she pregnant."

The volunteers often have their hearts ripped out when dogs and cats get euthanized, but it is even worse for the kennel attendants who actually have to do the killing. So much death is not healthy for normal people and it takes its toll. Many want a "No-Kill Philadelphia", and many have great opinions on the subject, but they are not chipping in to expand our services and facilities.”

Report Violation

27. logan said... on Jul 1, 2012 at 02:36PM

“#25 - well stated.

It's hard to believe no better candidates exist for CEO than same-o sue - a nightmare @ pacca - powertrippin @ pspca until unceremoniously dumped for a cambell"s soup executive - overall bad track record @ both places. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.

I admire staff and volunteers who work there. I call to foster animals and the staff are very cordial and up to date on information.

Report Violation

28. Anonymous said... on Jul 1, 2012 at 04:09PM

“This is a post made on a volunteer's PUBLIC Facebook page. This volunteer was upset about posts made by then Dog Evaluator, TJ Cunningham. It is a shame that he would post such flaming remarks on a volunteer's Facebook page.

February 4, 2012

8:36am. Yeah I have such a way....ACCT murdered her yesterday! Great job TJ!!!
18 hours ago. Oh no! That makes me sick. Is ACCT animal control? Who is TJ?
18 hours ago. Well it takes a lot to ruin my appetite, but that just did! Poor dog! We need more non-kill shelters desperately.
17 hours ago. The idiot who ordered her to be put to sleep. And would not give me one day to try to get her out of there. This is the harsh realities of the shelter.”

Report Violation

29. Anonymous said... on Jul 1, 2012 at 04:10PM

“17 hours ago. Im sorry for your loss but TJ is not the one to blame for this. The fact is we are a high kill shelter bc we are the only open door shelter in the entire city of Philadelphia and not because of TJ but because of the people who breed and dump their animals every day. Open door means ACCT cannot turn animals away. Blame the people who left her at the shelter. No Kill shelters are in theory great however they turn animals away and it doesn't mean they never euthanize like you may think. Spay/Neuter/Foster and Adopt!
17 hours ago • 1. They are to blame but so is he for this particular dog. That is my opinion and I was there. There was space enough to give her and me the courtesy of a few hours. I didn't even get the opportunity to say goodbye. he made a mistake and Precious is dead.”

Report Violation

30. Anonymous said... on Jul 1, 2012 at 04:15PM

“February 4, 2012

11 hours ago. Tj Cunningham: Food aggression does not relate to how a dog takes treats. knows all to well about T.I. and his food issues."
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham: 128 kennels, 138 dogs, do the math
11 hours ago. Do the math! You killed a deserving dog because you have no clue what you are doing.
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham: ooops...did I comment out loud? I'll delete!
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham What was the joke?
11 hours ago • 1.Tj Cunningham Its a math equation. I have X amount of kennels, I have Y amount of dogs...the Y is always larger than the X...its one of my jobs to equal out that amount
11 hours ago • 1.Tj Cunningham every single day
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham because I don't comment on these kind of posts
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham I like to comment on positive posts
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham I won't be hearing about anything...I have a specific job to do, I do that job”

Report Violation

31. Anonymous said... on Jul 1, 2012 at 04:16PM

“11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham there are very few people around willing to do this job
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham you have no idea what is concstructive
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham that made no sense
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham so you walked the kennels, took out a number of dogs last night, all of them I assume, because you know exactly what my job which dog would you have chosen instead?
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham what were you told?
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham doesn't matter. Complain away
11 hours ago.Tj Cunningham I encourage it

Report Violation

32. chris said... on Dec 23, 2014 at 10:18PM

“now she cut the hours back form all the volunteers hours back from helping the dogs at act wtf this bitch has to go !!”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

City's Animals in Danger—Again
By Tara Murtha

The PSPCA proposal is a sight to behold, stocked with swashbuckling campaign promises. On paper, it looked like 2009 would be a relatively good time to be a homeless animal in Philadelphia. Instead, disaster ensued.

Related Content

Can Sue Cosby Turn PSPCA Around?
By Tara Murtha

Baptism by fire, shit storm, train wreck: These are the nice ways to describe the situation that Sue Cosby -- the new CEO of the Pennsylvania Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals -- is hurling herself into. Earlier this week, Cosby talked with PW about her new role, her vision for the city’s animal control, and what a long, strange trip it’s been.

RELATED: Dog Day Afternoon The (Scary) Truth About Cats and Dogs Letters: Fur Keeps Michael Vick Comes To Philly Meeting of the Minds Calling All Dog Lovers: Emergency at PSPCA Shelter

Related Content

Board: More Animals Died in PSPCA Care Than Previously Reported
By Tara Murtha

Two weeks away from a City Hall investigational hearing called by Philadelphia City Councilman Jack Kelly to drill into the Pennsylvania Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (PSPCA)’s mismanagement of Philly’s animal control contract, the PSCPA is coming clean on euthanasia and save rate statistics.

RELATED: Worried Sick

Related Content

More About PSPCA: Cats Are Dying
By Barry Watson

An activist wants to know what is wrong with Philadelphia animal control.

Related Content

Ex-PSPCA CEO Now VP at Doggie Style
By Tara Murtha

Everyone who has worked directly with Howard Nelson—who in an earlier life was a Fannie Mae exec—has a strong opinion on him. His detractors are rapid; his supporters devout.

Related Content

Update: PSPCA’s “Population Break” Plan
By Tara Murtha

PSPCA employs dedicated animal-lover volunteers, but making sure these dogs are walked properly will be a challenge. Insiders have long said that on a regular day, there aren’t enough volunteers to walk the shelter dogs properly.