Fresh fruits and ve­get­ables on shelf in su­per­mar­ket. For healthy concept

In 1942, as World War II food ra­tion­ing ramped up and gro­cery shelves emp­tied, M.F.K. Fish­er wrote a wry, prac­tic­al little book called How to Cook a Wolf. The wolf she meant was the one at the door—and with tips for frugal dishes and a chapter titled, with grim de­term­in­a­tion, “How to Keep Alive,” Fish­er helped war­time Amer­ic­ans unite in fa­cing the real­it­ies of food in­sec­ur­ity to­geth­er. “Use as many fresh things as you can, al­ways, and then trust to luck,” she wrote. 

Walk the abund­ant halls of the Read­ing Ter­min­al Mar­ket or browse the bounty of the Head­house Square Farm­ers’ Mar­ket, and you might be for­giv­en for think­ing that the wolf has long since aban­doned Phil­adelphia. The in­genu­ity of chefs and mix­o­lo­gists and food-truck op­er­at­ors has brought us in­to the ranks of Amer­ica’s best food cit­ies, to hear the Wash­ing­ton Post, Travel + Leis­ure, Za­gat and many oth­ers tell it; gour­mets, ve­gans, and glu­ten-free pa­leo di­eters all find plenty of op­tions here. Yet, amid all this culin­ary in­nov­a­tion, a stag­ger­ing one-fourth of Phil­adelphi­ans struggle with hun­ger and food in­sec­ur­ity, ac­cord­ing to the Hun­ger Co­ali­tion.

The wolf is at the doors of too many row­houses—but this wolf is a dif­fer­ent spe­cies than the one that stalked the city dur­ing World War II. For one thing, war ra­tion­ing was more or less uni­ver­sal; the sac­ri­fice was by no means equal, but it was cer­tainly shared. Today, though, in­come in­equal­ity has skyrock­eted—great­er Phil­adelphia is now the na­tion’s second most un­equal urb­an area, ac­cord­ing to a 2015 study. Lux­ury and poverty ex­ist side by side here.

What’s more, war­time cooks could eas­ily buy or grow pro­duce—what they lacked was “lux­ury” items like but­ter, sug­ar, and meat. Today’s food sys­tem is in­dus­tri­al, on the oth­er hand. Mass-pro­duced foods, their taste bulked up with fat, salt, sug­ar, and ar­ti­fi­cial fla­vor­ings, are now what’s cheap—and, in much of the city, far easi­er to buy than fresh, un­pro­cessed foods. You can find bagged snacks, fast food, and mi­crowave­able meals at every corner store, but for many res­id­ents—es­pe­cially those who rely on pub­lic trans­it—gro­cery stores are hard to come by, let alone the butchers, bakers, and pro­duce stands that were neigh­bor­hood staples in Fish­er’s day. Areas with low su­per­mar­ket ac­cess—some­times called “food deserts”—still dot the city map; statewide; more than two mil­lion Pennsylvani­ans lack ac­cess to fresh food.

At Fat Mom’s Lunch­eon­ette, in a low-su­per­mar­ket-ac­cess sec­tion of Port Rich­mond, a few green pep­pers, ba­na­nas, onions, to­ma­toes and pep­pers is offered along­side the deli meats. What doesn’t sell is used to make pre­pared food in the kit­chen, and prices are high enough (pota­toes are $1.25 each!) and se­lec­tion small enough to de­ter all but a few neigh­bors in need.

Res­id­ents aren’t just deal­ing with out-of-reach stores and rising prices—they’re also strug­gling to work mul­tiple jobs or patch “gig eco­nomy” work to­geth­er, find re­li­able and af­ford­able child care, and ob­tain hous­ing with ad­equate kit­chen fa­cil­it­ies. All of that has a big im­pact on what and wheth­er fam­il­ies cook. Yet, too of­ten, the ser­i­ous health prob­lems that come with a lack of ac­cess to healthy food are framed in terms of in­di­vidu­al de­cisions; low-in­come people just need to “make re­spons­ible choices,” we’re told. This sort of pa­ter­nal­ist­ic head-pat­ting was, for ex­ample, a com­mon ar­gu­ment in fa­vor of the eco­nom­ic­ally re­gress­ive soda tax, which tar­gets soda rather than the sug­ary bever­ages pre­ferred by middle-class con­sumers. 

De­velopers of­ten op­er­ate on a sim­il­ar lo­gic—as­sum­ing, for in­stance, that gro­cery stores in low-in­come areas won’t be prof­it­able be­cause res­id­ents won’t buy fresh foods. That’s wrong, ac­cord­ing to Ju­lia Ko­prak, seni­or as­so­ci­ate at the Food Trust, a non­profit or­gan­iz­a­tion that aims to im­prove food ac­cess in Phil­adelphia, in­clud­ing work­ing to loc­ate gro­cery stores and farm­ers’ mar­kets in neigh­bor­hoods that need them and part­ner­ing with gov­ern­ment food as­sist­ance pro­grams to provide farm­ers’ mar­ket ac­cess and cook­ing classes. While there isn’t much hard data, she says, “What we hear an­ec­dot­ally is from gro­cers in un­der­served areas is that their pro­duce sales are com­par­able to or above sales in sub­urb­an areas. There’s a myth that people won’t buy fruits and ve­get­ables, but if you listen to the com­munity about their needs and of­fer a range of foods that’s af­ford­able and cul­tur­ally ap­pro­pri­ate, people ab­so­lutely do buy and cook those foods.” 

The Food Trust and sev­er­al oth­er groups have re­cently brought health care pro­viders and edu­cat­ors in­to the pro­cess. St. Chris­toph­er’s Hos­pit­al for Chil­dren has doc­tors write pre­scrip­tions for fresh fruits and ve­get­ables; pa­tients and com­munity mem­bers with SNAP be­ne­fits can also sign up for the Farms to Fam­il­ies pro­gram, which provides low-cost weekly pro­duce boxes year-round. In the Phil­adelphia Pub­lic Schools, nu­tri­tion edu­cat­ors vis­it classrooms to con­duct fruit and ve­get­able tast­ings as part of the Fresh Fruit and Ve­get­able Pro­gram, a USDA fed­er­al pro­gram be­ing pi­loted in sev­er­al states. Ele­ment­ary-aged kids try new foods, learn about nu­tri­tion, and re­ceive re­cipes to take home. 

Much pro­gress was made between 2004 and 2010 un­der the aus­pices of the Fresh Food Fin­an­cing Ini­ti­at­ive, an in­nov­at­ive Pennsylvania state pro­gram that made grants to re­tail­ers of all sizes. As well as help­ing to open new stores, in­clud­ing the Fresh Gro­cer on North Broad and the Shop­Rite on Park­side Av­en­ue, the pro­gram’s Healthy Corner Store Ini­ti­at­ive brought re­fri­ger­at­ors and fresh pro­duce to more than 600 corner stores around the city, so the staples of healthy meals are offered along­side the usu­al chips and ci­gar­ettes. Re­new­ing FF­FI would go a long way to­ward con­tinu­ing to ad­dress what is still a ser­i­ous prob­lem, says Ko­prak.

It’s hard to track the im­pact of such pro­grams on adults’ health out­comes, Ko­prak says, be­cause dis­ease rates change slowly. Chil­dren’s health, on the oth­er hand, can be tracked more quickly. “One thing we’ve seen that’s pretty ma­jor is a re­duc­tion in child­hood obesity in Phil­adelphia by five per­cent,” she adds, cit­ing a study by the city’s De­part­ment of Pub­lic Health over five years of FF­FI pro­gress.

“To as­sert and re­as­sert our dig­nity in the face of poverty,” as Fish­er put it, “is to nour­ish ourselves with all pos­sible skill, del­ic­acy, and ever-in­creas­ing en­joy­ment.” Most people want to eat well, giv­en the chance—so be­fore you cri­ti­cize your neigh­bors, ask how you can help ex­pand ac­cess to fresh food every­where in the city.

Twit­ter: @GreyEd­it­ing


(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.