50 things you must eat in Philly

By PW Staff
Add Comment Add Comment | Comments: 17 | Posted Nov. 7, 2012

Share this Story:

Here’s what we love about food in Philadelphia: everything. No, seriously. From the street vendor’s commonest cheesesteak to the most subtly spiced French-Asian hybrid delicacy, it’s all good. But some of it? Some of it is awesome. So here are 50 suggestions for dishes, ranging from sophisticated to speedy, that you’ve just got to try—whether you’re in town for the day or here for keeps.

Meat & Fish

Fried chicken at Federal Donuts
1219 S. Second St. 267.687.8258. federaldonuts.com
Why it’s great : It’s a gusty move indeed to try to bring the heretofore niche glories of Korean fried chicken ($9–$17) to the masses, but that’s exactly what Federal Donuts has done here, and with gusto. Shattering skin, incomprehensibly moist flesh, and a use of spice unrivaled anywhere.
What to have with it : Doughnuts, of course ($1.25–$2 each). OK, not with them, but afterward. And it doesn’t matter what kind, either: Indian cinnamon, Creamsicle, vanilla-lavender and more. They’re all hot, unexpectedly complex miracles.

Beer-battered fish and chips at Dandelion
124 S. 18th St. 215.558.2500. thedandelionpub.com
Why it’s great : In a world where so many versions of this English classic are flaccid and vaguely depressing, Dandelion’s Chatham cod is meaty and perfectly crunchy, and the fries—well, they are what all potatoes wish to become when they die. ($19.50)
What to have with it : A beer, preferably one of the hand-pumped casks here. Cellar-temperature ale with a great plate of fish and chips is one of the top pairings in the world.

Roast pork and roast duck noodle soup at Sang Kee
238 N. 9th St. 215.925.7532. sangkeechinatown.com
Why it’s great : The hangover remedy of choice for a generation of Philadelphians is as good today as it’s ever been. The honey-sweet pork, the funky cuts of duck, the fat globules glistening atop the broth: It’s a better remedy for a rough night out or a cold winter afternoon than any over-the-counter medication. Cheaper, too. ($7.25)
What to have with it : Hair of the dog: Beer. An ice-cold Tsingtao alongside this is perfect. So, too, is an accompanying dish of fried wontons.

Tacos at Taqueria La Veracruzana
908 Washington Ave. 215.465.1440.
Why it’s great : It’s hard to find a better way to spend $6 than on these three soft-shell beauties. My go-to selection includes al pastor (with pineapple), casing-less chorizo with its oil glistening at the surface, and jalapeño rellenos, whose queso fresco filling is almost—but not quite—enough to balance out the heat of that pepper.
What to have with it : Jarritos Tamarindo soda, and an order of the silky guacamole with just-oily-enough tortilla chips.

Pig’s head at Alla Spina
1410 Mt. Vernon St. 215.600.0017. allaspinaphilly.com
Why it’s great : Because it’s a whole pig’s head, that’s why. Because all the little succulent bits and pieces that you usually don’t get a chance to chow on—the nubs behind the mandible, the tongue like a piece of candy, the pillowy, almost gamy eyeballs. And because with its glistening, taut skin, it’s a pork-lover’s fantasy come to life.
What to have with it : Beer. Or lambrusco. Just make sure there are bubbles and enough acid or bitterness to slice through all that succulence.

Cheesesteak Pretzel at Philly Pretzel Factory
1532 Sansom St., 215.569.3988, phillysoftpretzelfactory.com
Why it’s great : If we were recommending, in and of themselves, those archetypal Philly street foods, the cheesesteak or pretzel—and we will soon—we’d send you elsewhere. But what if you want the sublime experience of having a hot, gooey Philly cheesesteak baked right goddamn inside your pretzel? Here’s a hint: You do. ($3.50)
What to have with it : The Factory’s just a take-out counter, so pop a few doors down the block and pick up one of the city’s best milkshakes at 500 Degrees. Recommended: chocolate banana ($5.75) or dulche ($5.50).

Chicken and waffles at Sbraga
440 S. Broad St. 215.735.1913. sbraga.com
Why it’s great : An occasional special on the new “breakfast at dinner” menu at Sbraga, this is reason enough to skip your real breakfast and hold out the 12 hours until dinnertime. The chicken itself is majestic—textbook crust, generous meat—but laid atop the waffle and dragged through the foie gras butter, it’s astounding.
What to have with it : Spirits magician Anwar Morgan mixed up, tableside, a maple-bacon rye manhattan that echoed even more flavors of the breakfast table, and re-imagined one of the great cocktails in a wholly new, thoroughly exciting way.

Lardo Pizza at Barbuzzo
110 S. 13th St. 215.546.9300. barbuzzo.com/barbuzzo
Why it’s great : Anything with “lardo” in the name is OK by me, but this pie sails even beyond the majestically succulent heights its name implies. And while the combination of hen-of-the-woods mushrooms, taleggio, rosemary and artichoke is near perfect, it’s the lardo cured in-house that blasts it all into the stratosphere. ($14)
What to have with it : A brightly acidic red wine or, perhaps even better, a hoppy beer to cut through those pieces of lardo.

Bone marrow at Bibou
1009 S. 8th St. 215.965.8290. biboubyob.com
Why it’s great : Sauteed with homemade breadcrumbs, a gorgeous selection of mushrooms that changes regularly, shallots, garlic, parsley and heaping portion of love, this bone-canoe plating is toe-curlingly delicious. If there’s one dish in the city worth demolishing your cholesterol count for, this is it. ($24)
What to have with it : Wine, wine and more wine. (Bibou is a BYOB.) There are a number of directions you could go with this dish: A crisp white to cut through the food’s richness, an earthy red to pair with it, or a glass of Champagne, which to me seems just about the perfect choice.

Any burger at Pub & Kitchen
1946 Lombard St. 215.545.0350. thepubandkitchen.com
Why they’re great : The burgers here are reliably among the best in the city. And unlike so many others, these are all about the quality of the beef, not necessarily the baroque-ness of the toppings.
What to have with them : It’s a tough call here, but you can’t go wrong with a perfectly poured beer from their always interesting selection, or—and I’m generally not really a big proponent of cocktails with dinner—a barrel-aged manhattan, which really is that spectacular.

Crabfries at Chickie’s & Pete’s
Various locations. chickiesandpetes.com
Why it’s great : French fries with a choke-worthy helping of Old Bay seasoning can be found masquerading as Crabfries® on many menus around town, but the trademarked original lives at Chickie’s & Pete’s. Each basket of crispy-yet-soft deep-fried potatoes is bathed in a secret blend of delicious spices that stick to every nook and cranny of the crinkly-cut fries. Once it was served with only one measly cup of their pour-it-all-over-anything-you-order white cheese sauce, but the owners have finally come to their senses and doubled up the helping with each order. You’re welcome.
What to have with it : Who cares? TWO servings of cheese sauce!

El Ranchero at Sazon
941 Spring Garden St. 215.763.2500. sazonrestaurant.com
Why it’s great : It’s not just that this Mexican-style scramble is appealing to carnivores and veggie lovers alike, loaded with spicy chorizo, red and green peppers, jalapeños, onions and tomatoes. The real draw at this delightful Venezuelen BYOB is the quality of the ingredients. Chef Judith Suzarra-Campbell cooks exclusively with olive oil, locally raised free-range eggs, local dairy and produce, and has an extensive corn-based gluten-free menu. ($11.)
What to have with it : A mug of drinking chocolate made by Judy’s husband Bob, the “chocolate alchemist.” Try the Clasico (with five different cacao beans) or El Orgasmo (come to me, peanut butter, Kahlua and fresh banana). (Prices vary.)

Charbroiled pork banh mi at Pho Cali
1000 Arch St. 215.629.1888.
Why it’s great : The price of these forearm-long sandwiches recently went up ... to still less than $5. For that almost inconceivably low number, you get a generous helping of sweet-smoky pork, crisp pickled vegetables, and a bun toasted so perfectly that the crumb is still moist inside the wafer-thin warmth of the crust.
What to have with it : Sriracha. Not too much, of course, but a generous squiggle will set up the other flavors nicely.

Braised chicken and biscuits with herbs at The Mildred
824 S. Eighth St. 267.687.1600. the-mildred.com
Why it’s great : For $8, what you get is a filling, hearty cast-iron skillet of poultry love, replete with biscuits of greater soulfulness than most ever achieve. More, please!
What to have with it : A beer would be great, but a glass of amontillado or oloroso sherry, or even a slightly oxidized-tasting white, would be perfect. (Note: Brian Freedman consulted on the beverage program at The Mildred.) And make sure you get a basket of homemade bread to sop up all the wonderful leftovers sticking to the bottom of the dish.

The Catalan Express lunch at Amada
217-219 Chestnut St. 215.625.2450. amadarestaurant.com
Why it’s great : Not only is the price right—$14.50 for soup and either a sandwich or salad, plus an iced tea or soda—but the options are more than generous. I love the skirt steak pepito sandwich with Cabrales cheese and gorgeously caramelized onions preceded by caldo gallego, a Galician stew of ham and beans.
What to have with it : It may not be included, but since you’re saving so much money on the lunch itself, spring for a class of wine, preferably something crisp and refreshing, to wash it all down. Just because it’s midday doesn’t mean a drink is verboten.

Honey Dean sausage at Honey’s Sit ‘n Eat
800 N. 4th St. 215.925.1150. honeyssitneat.com
Why it’s great : There’s no shortage of great ground-meat products in this city, but this one ($3) is consistently one of the best. It’s an innocent-looking patty that packs a serious punch, the honey sweetness balanced out by a gentle spicy tingle. Dragged through a fried egg’s yolk at breakfast, it’s possibly the simplest, most heartfelt forkful you’ll eat all day.
What to have with it : The potato latke ($2.50), a fried wedge of crispety-crunchety carbolicious goodness.

Chinese Five Spiced Peking Duck Breast at Bistro 7
7 N. 3rd St. 215.931.1560. bistro7restaurant.com
Why it’s great : There’s a reason that Chef Michael O’Halloran’s Old City standout has been around for so long: Because it’s so consistently, remarkably good. And this dish embodies much of what makes it so: Generous seasoning, perfect cooking temps and the kind of complex flavor that keep you coming back for far more bites than you probably really need. ($32)
What to have with it : Find a bottle of good Pinot Noir, or a Bordeaux with a couple of years of age to it, pop the corks, and don’t get up till your plate is clean and the bottle is empty.

Page: 1 2 3 |Next
Add to favoritesAdd to Favorites PrintPrint Send to friendSend to Friend


Comments 1 - 17 of 17
Report Violation

1. Tom Cash said... on Nov 7, 2012 at 12:26PM

“Great list, one other must have - meatball sliders at Village Belle. At least one a week with a cold Peroni draft makes for the start of a good night!”

Report Violation

2. Betty Ortiz said... on Nov 7, 2012 at 01:44PM

“Great list. Besides El Ranchero and Robert's clasico and orgasmo chocolate, Judy makes the best sancocho soup (venezuelan beef soup)! Love the fresh ingredients and glutten free menu!

Report Violation

3. Kristy from 22nd & Philly said... on Nov 7, 2012 at 03:51PM

“We've reviewed and can vouch for many of these as can't miss dishes in Philadelphia, especially the tonnarelli at Amis, cheese plate at Talula's Garden and ribs at Blue Belly BBQ. Have to disagree on the cheesesteak pretzel location - Miller's Twist in Reading Terminal Market makes a better one. We send people there all the time. Also the burgerS at Pub & Kitchen are now down to just one burger that hasn't been as satisfying as they used to be.”

Report Violation

4. Anonymous said... on Nov 8, 2012 at 09:49AM

“Dear Philly,

Stop throwing Old Bay on french fries and calling them "crab fries." We put old bay on EVERYTHING and don't go around calling dishes crab eggs, crab fried chicken,etc. To have a crab fry, you need to have CRAB somewhere in the recipe!


Report Violation

5. Carl said... on Nov 8, 2012 at 10:14AM

“I did find it funny that crab fries was listed under meat and fish dishes. But, it is quite a list I will have to get started on.”

Report Violation

6. brian m said... on Nov 8, 2012 at 01:11PM

“Yo!.you guys missed the pierogi hoagie @ green rock tavern....”

Report Violation

7. Donna said... on Nov 8, 2012 at 02:08PM

“The Montreal french fries and chicken pot pies at Noir on Passyunk are the

Report Violation

8. Dallas said... on Nov 8, 2012 at 08:53PM

“How could this list be complete without SKETCH on E. Girard Ave???”

Report Violation

9. Anonymous said... on Nov 9, 2012 at 07:17AM

“Born and raised in Philly, and absolutely hate Baltimore, but the complaint is right... Chickie and Pete's does NOT qualify as actual crab fries. For real lump crab fries 100x better, go to Taproom on 19th. It's deep South Philly, in a little bar, but well worth the trip.”

Report Violation

10. Epices6 said... on Nov 9, 2012 at 07:59AM

“Fun list (and on the mark many times). I agree with Kristy that Miller's Twist makes better pretzels. On my list: the charcuterie plate at Kraftwork (a great start to a fine beer night) and soups at Taco Riendo.
A bust: the pig's head at Alla Spina: overpriced, overcooked, with a gooey lacquer - not worth it!”

Report Violation

11. DadGerry said... on Nov 9, 2012 at 09:30AM

“. . . without a specialty hot dog & hand-cut fries from "HOT DIGGITY" on South Street? . . . you're kidding, right? The place, staff & food ROCK!”

Report Violation

12. jamie said... on Nov 9, 2012 at 03:37PM

“And you missed the burger at Greenrock too!
Best fries in philly!!!!!”

Report Violation

13. Anonymous said... on Nov 10, 2012 at 12:16PM

“I completely disagree with the necessity of Chickie and Pete's Crab Fries on this list. They are gross. And as someone else already pointed out--they don't even have crab on them!
If you want real crab fries that are so fantastic they defy words, go to The Tap Room on 19th at 19th and Ritner. Tons of fresh cut fries, with huge chunks of crabmeat throughout, a delicious cheese sauce, scallions and oh yeah, old bay seasoning.”

Report Violation

14. greg said... on Nov 12, 2012 at 01:18PM

“Bloody Beet Steak at Farm And Fisherman should have been on there.

Report Violation

15. Susan said... on Nov 12, 2012 at 03:07PM

“You have to try Tarts for dessert. It's a tiny little bakery around 2nd and Arch. The tarts are delicious and they have a variety of different combination of fruit.”

Report Violation

16. Anonymous said... on Nov 16, 2012 at 12:19PM

“Ice Cream donut from Frangelli's in S. Philly.....nuff said”

Report Violation

17. mickman said... on May 9, 2014 at 07:08AM

“EVERYTHING at Cochon”


(HTML and URLs prohibited)

Related Content

Philly's 50 Must-Eats
By Adam Erace, Tim McGinnis and Brian McManus

PW has compiled a list of the 50 best things to eat and drink in Philly rightthisverymoment. We’ve included—in no particular order—some entrenched favorites (Osteria pizza, Cape May Salts) but mostly illuminated the new and newly discovered: everything from offbeat beers (Alehoof Grut) to cheeses with stories to tell (Mancuso ricotta). They might just become your next favorites. They’re already ours. 

RELATED: The Food Issue: 50-Plus Things You Must Eat & Drink Philly's 50 Must-Eats: The Contest